# ERISA disability appeal record review

> ERISA disability appeal record review: functional limitations, objective findings, treating and reviewer opinions and gaps, cited by page before the appeal.

Canonical page: https://medrecords.ai/solutions/erisa-attorneys/

---
New — **Missing Records Detection:** flags every visit, provider, and date missing from the file. [See how →](https://medrecords.ai/product/missing-records-identification/)
1. [Solutions](https://medrecords.ai/solutions/)
2. ERISA Disability Attorneys

## ERISA disability appeal record review for attorneys

*Treating opinions, reviewer opinions and the findings behind each, every line traced to its page in the claim file.*

ERISA disability appeal record review. Medrecords AI reads the claim file and the medical records and lays out functional limitations, restrictions, objective findings, treating and reviewing physician opinions, and gaps by date, every line cited to its page, so the record is built before the appeal closes it. You review it, and you write the appeal.

Updated 21 Nov 2026

At a glance
| Built for | Attorneys handling long-term disability denials and appeals under ERISA |
| --- | --- |
| What it reads | The claim file, the denial letter, reviewer reports, treating records, FCEs, imaging, test results and SSA files |
| Functional limitations | Every sitting, standing, lifting and hours limit, who wrote it and the date |
| Objective findings | Imaging, EMG, lab and exam findings by date, with the page |
| Opinions | Treating and reviewing physician opinions side by side, with the records each one lists |
| Gaps | Records the notes refer to that are not in the claim file |
| Appeal window | Built early in the 180-day appeal window, while records can still be added |
| Speed | About 1 hour per case |
| Price | From 10 cents per deduplicated page, as low as 5 cents with volume |
| Security | SOC 2 and HIPAA, BAA at signup |
| Trial | First case is free on us |
| What it does not do | It does not give legal or medical opinions, score the case, write the appeal or request records |

[In a sample 342-page, 2-packet production, Medrecords AI found 11 duplicate pages.](https://medrecords.ai/product/medical-record-deduplication/) You pay for unique pages only.

[Book a demo ](https://medrecords.ai/demo/) [See it on a timeline](https://medrecords.ai/solutions/erisa-attorneys/#cl-tl)
- HIPAA, under a BAA
- SOC 2
- About 1 hour per case
- First case is free on us

**1 claimant, 1 LTD claim, 2.5 years of records** — tap a point
denial received · 14 Aug 2026
Findings and function
Opinions and decisions
2024 — 2025 — 2026
28 Jul 2026Reviewing physician report — Opinions and decisions
No objective findings support restrictions. Full-time sedentary work. Records reviewed: no EMG listed.

p. 41 — conflicts with p. 231
Illustrative case. The claimant, plan, providers, dates and pages are fictional.
1 hourper case, on average
How long a typical case takes after upload.

Medrecords AI
180 daysto appeal
The minimum time a disability plan must give a claimant to appeal an adverse benefit determination.

29 CFR 2560.503-1(h)(3)(i)
45 dayson review
The usual time a plan has to decide a disability appeal, instead of the 60 days for other claims.

29 CFR 2560.503-1(i)(3)(i)
11duplicate pages
Found in a sample 342-page, 2-packet production before billing.

Medrecords AI

### Who should use ERISA disability appeal record review?

Attorneys and their paralegals who take long-term disability clients after a denial and build the appeal before the plan's review closes. If you spend the first week of every appeal reading a 1,500-page claim file to find what the reviewing physician skipped, it is built for you. If your cases arrive after the appeal, at the lawsuit stage under 29 U.S.C. 1132, the record is already set and you need it less.

Related services, guides and samples
[Long-term disability claim file review](https://medrecords.ai/solutions/long-term-disability/) [Disability representatives](https://medrecords.ai/solutions/disability-representatives/) [Disability insurers](https://medrecords.ai/solutions/disability-insurers/) [Social Security disability](https://medrecords.ai/solutions/social-security-disability/) [Functional capacity evaluations](https://medrecords.ai/guides/functional-capacity-evaluation/) [Medical source statements](https://medrecords.ai/guides/medical-source-statement-rfc/) [Missing Records Detection](https://medrecords.ai/product/missing-records-identification/) [Page citations](https://medrecords.ai/product/citations/) [Deduplication](https://medrecords.ai/product/medical-record-deduplication/) [Security and HIPAA](https://medrecords.ai/security/)

### Does Medrecords AI write the appeal or judge the claim?

No. It lays out what the claim file and the medical records say, by date, with pages: the limitations, the findings, the opinions on both sides and what is missing. The legal theory, the evidence you add and the appeal itself are yours.

### What should medical record review for an ERISA long-term disability appeal find?

The appeal is the claimant's chance to add comments, documents and records to the file the plan decides on, in the full and fair review that 29 U.S.C. 1133 requires. The denial usually turns on a few claims about the medical evidence. These are the 6 things Medrecords AI pulls out of the claim file and the records you add, each flagged with its page.

Function

#### Functional limitations

Every sitting, standing, walking, lifting and hours limit from treating notes, FCEs and medical source statements, with the date and who wrote it.

functional limitationsFindings

#### Objective findings

Imaging, nerve studies, labs and exam findings by date, so a denial that says no objective findings sits next to the pages that show them.

objective findingsTreating

#### Treating physician opinions

What each treating doctor wrote about work capacity, restrictions and prognosis, with the page and the visit it came from.

treating physicianReviewer

#### Reviewing physician opinions

What each file reviewer concluded and the list of records the report says were reviewed, so a missing EMG or FCE shows.

reviewing physicianOther

#### SSA and other decisions

Any Social Security award, prior approval or other disability finding in the file, with its date and page.

SSA awardGaps

#### Missing records

Missing Records Detection lists each visit, test and procedure the notes mention that never reached the claim file.

missing records

### How do the treating physician and the reviewing physician compare?

The same fictional claimant, line by line. The treating orthopedist and the FCE limit sitting. The reviewing physician says no objective findings, and the EMG is not on his list of records reviewed.

| Date | Source | Finding | Page | Flag |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| 16 Feb 2024 | Lumbar MRI | L5 to S1 disc extrusion contacting the left S1 root. | p. 212 | objective finding |
| 2 May 2024 | EMG report | Acute left S1 radiculopathy. | p. 231 | objective finding |
| Apr 2026 | No injection record | Epidural injection referred to. No procedure note in the file. | none | missing record |
| 11 Jun 2026 | Functional capacity evaluation | Sitting 25 minutes at a time, 3.5 hours a day. | p. 288 | functional limitation |

| Date | Source | Finding | Page | Flag |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| 6 Feb 2025 | SSA notice of award | Social Security disability benefits awarded. | p. 301 | SSA award |
| 24 Jun 2026 | Treating orthopedist | No sitting over 30 minutes at a time. 4 hours a day at most. | p. 276 | treating opinion |
| 28 Jul 2026 | Reviewing physician report | No objective findings. Full-time sedentary work. EMG not listed. | p. 41 | conflicts with p. 231 |
| 12 Aug 2026 | Denial letter | Benefits end. No discussion of the SSA award. | p. 3 | adverse determination |

Fictional case built for this page. Real output has the same columns, and every page links to the source PDF.

### What goes into an appeal record review, and what comes back?

#### What you send

- The claim file you requested from the plan
- The denial letter and every reviewer report
- Treating records, imaging and test results
- FCEs, medical source statements and vocational reports
- SSA files and any prior approval letters
- Any format: PDFs, scans, faxes, handwriting

#### What you get

- Functional limitations and restrictions by date
- Objective findings with pages
- Treating and reviewing opinions side by side
- The records each reviewer lists, and the ones they do not
- SSA and other decisions with dates
- A missing-records list before the record closes

#### We build the record. You write the appeal.

Medrecords AI does not give legal or medical opinions, judge whether the claimant is disabled, score the case, value the claim or request records. It puts what the file says in order, with pages. You review the summary, check any line against its page, and decide what the appeal argues and what evidence to add.

**HIPAA, BAA at signup** — Every claim file is handled under our Business Associate Agreement.
**SOC 2** — Encrypted in transit and at rest, with every PHI access logged.
**No model training** — Client files never train any AI model, ours or anyone else's.
**Deletion on request** — You set retention, and files are deleted when you ask.

### Which functional limitations does the file support, and who wrote them?

In this fictional file, the denial turns on whether the claimant can sit through a full workday. Medrecords AI lists every limit in the file, from treating notes, the FCE and any medical source statement, with the date and who wrote it. Under [29 CFR 2560.503-1](https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-29/section-2560.503-1), the claimant may submit written comments, documents and records on appeal, and the review has to take them into account. What you add is your call.

| Date | Source | Limitation | Page | Flag |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| 14 Mar 2024 | Treating orthopedist | Off work. Recheck in 6 weeks. | p. 220 | treating opinion |
| 3 Oct 2025 | Treating orthopedist | Sitting 30 minutes at a time. Lifting 10 lb. | p. 268 | treating opinion |
| 11 Jun 2026 | Functional capacity evaluation | Sitting 25 minutes at a time, 3.5 hours a day. | p. 288 | functional limitation |
| 24 Jun 2026 | Treating orthopedist | 4 hours of work a day at most. | p. 276 | treating opinion |
| 28 Jul 2026 | Reviewing physician report | Full-time sedentary work with no limits. | p. 41 | conflicts with p. 288 |

### Where are the objective findings the denial says are missing?

A denial that says "no objective findings" can be checked against the file page by page. Medrecords AI pulls imaging, nerve studies and exam findings by date and sets them next to the reviewer's list of records reviewed. The regulation also asks a disability denial to explain why it disagrees with treating providers and with an SSA decision the claimant presented. Whether this denial does is your read.

| Date | Source | Finding | Page | Flag |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| 16 Feb 2024 | Lumbar MRI | L5 to S1 disc extrusion contacting the left S1 root. | p. 212 | objective finding |
| 2 May 2024 | EMG report | Acute left S1 radiculopathy. | p. 231 | objective finding |
| 3 Oct 2025 | Orthopedic exam | Positive straight leg raise on the left. Absent left ankle reflex. | p. 268 | objective finding |
| 28 Jul 2026 | Reviewing physician report | Records reviewed list omits the EMG. | p. 41 | not reviewed |
| 12 Aug 2026 | Denial letter | No discussion of the SSA award on p. 301. | p. 3 | not addressed |

### What belongs in the administrative record before it closes?

The appeal is the last chance to add records. Medrecords AI lists every visit, test and procedure the notes mention that is not in the claim file, with the page that mentions it. The SSA standard in [20 CFR 404.1505](https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-20/section-404.1505) differs from most plan definitions, so the award and its file sit on their own line. What to request and file is yours.

| Date | Record mentioned | Where it is mentioned | Page | Flag |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Apr 2026 | Epidural injection procedure note | Orthopedic note, 24 Jun 2026 | p. 276 | missing record |
| 2025 | Physical therapy notes, 16 visits | Orthopedic note, 3 Oct 2025 | p. 268 | missing record |
| Feb 2025 | SSA medical file behind the award | SSA notice of award | p. 301 | missing record |
| Jun 2026 | Vocational assessment | Denial letter | p. 3 | relied on, not in file |

### ERISA disability appeal record review: common questions

**Does Medrecords AI write the appeal or judge the claim?**
No. It lays out what the claim file and the medical records say, by date, with pages: the limitations, the findings, the opinions on both sides and what is missing. The legal theory, the evidence you add and the appeal itself are yours.

**Does it compare treating and reviewing physician opinions?**
Yes. Each opinion on work capacity is listed with who wrote it, whether they treated or only reviewed the file, the date and the page, so the 2 sides sit next to each other.

**Can it show which records a reviewer did not look at?**
It lists the records each reviewer report says were reviewed next to the records in the file. A test or visit missing from that list is flagged with its page.

**Does it request the claim file from the plan?**
No. Medrecords AI does not retrieve records. You upload the claim file you received from the plan and any records you collected.

**Can it handle a claim file of several thousand pages?**
Yes. It reads PDFs, scans, faxes and handwriting, removes exact duplicate pages, and returns the summary in about 1 hour per case on average.

**Does it flag records that are missing from the claim file?**
Yes. Missing Records Detection lists each visit, test and procedure the notes mention that is not in the file, so you can request it before the appeal record closes.

**Does it tell me whether the claimant is disabled?**
No. It does not give legal or medical opinions or score the case. It shows what the records say so you can decide what to argue.

**Is it HIPAA compliant?**
Yes. Files are handled under a BAA signed at signup with SOC 2 controls. They never train an AI model, and they are deleted on request. Your client's right to copies of their own records under 45 CFR 164.524 is often how treating records reach you.

**Does it work for short-term disability and life waiver of premium claims?**
Yes. The record work is the same: limitations, findings and opinions by date, with pages. The legal work stays with you.

**What does it cost?**
From 10 cents per deduplicated page, as low as 5 cents with volume. Duplicate pages are free, and the first case is free on us.

### Build the record before it closes. The first case is free on us.

Book a short demo. After it we open trial access on one of your own LTD claim files, the first case free on us, with the summary back page-cited.

[Book a demo ](https://medrecords.ai/demo/) [See pricing](https://medrecords.ai/pricing/)

### Sources

Every rule, regulation, statute and published standard named on this page is linked below to the text the body that issues it puts out, read on the date shown. Where a standard is sold rather than published, the link goes to its publisher's page for it.

- [29 CFR 2560.503-1, claims procedure](https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-29/section-2560.503-1): eCFR, read 21 Nov 2026
- [29 U.S.C. 1133, claims procedure](https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCODE-2023-title29/html/USCODE-2023-title29-chap18-subchapI-subtitleB-part5-sec1133.htm): U.S. Government Publishing Office, read 21 Nov 2026
- [29 U.S.C. 1132, civil enforcement](https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCODE-2023-title29/html/USCODE-2023-title29-chap18-subchapI-subtitleB-part5-sec1132.htm): U.S. Government Publishing Office, read 21 Nov 2026
- [20 CFR 404.1505, basic definition of disability](https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-20/section-404.1505): eCFR, read 21 Nov 2026
- [45 CFR 164.524, access of individuals to protected health information](https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-45/section-164.524): eCFR, read 21 Nov 2026

### More solutions

- [**For IME clinics, networks & coordinators** — Medical record review for IME clinics, networks, and coordinators: referral intake to report delivery…](https://medrecords.ai/solutions/ime/)
- [**Hospital risk management chart review services** — Hospital risk management chart review: the adverse event chart in 1 page-cited timeline for incident review…](https://medrecords.ai/solutions/hospital-risk-management/)
- [**Long-term disability claim file review** — Claim files, peer reviews, surveillance, and FCEs read into 1 cited chronology, with a point-by-point response…](https://medrecords.ai/solutions/long-term-disability/)
- [**Mass tort intake and claimant screening** — Mass tort intake screening: proof of use, diagnosis and dates pulled for each claimant, page-cited, so your…](https://medrecords.ai/solutions/mass-tort-intake/)
- [**Mass tort medical record review** — AI mass tort medical record review: 1 set of qualification criteria run across every claimant file, fact sheets…](https://medrecords.ai/solutions/mass-tort-case-review/)
- [**Medical record review for claims adjusters** — Medical record review for claims adjusters: bodily injury files with treatment gaps, prior injuries and billing…](https://medrecords.ai/solutions/claims-adjusters/)
