NewMissing Records Detection: flags every visit, provider, and date missing from the file. See how →

How the AI record review study was built

The reports in this series count what vendors publish on their own sites. This page explains how, what the counts cannot tell you, and which sources the reports share.

By Ahmed Jemaa, Co-Founder & CEO of Medrecords AI · Published 5 Nov 2026

What we did

  1. We built a vendor pool from 2 owned corpora: a 55-site competitor scrape captured on 2026-08-13, and 328 live company profiles from the Medrecords AI content hub.
  2. We ran 4 targeted discovery passes for the audiences the pool covered thinly: legal nurse consultants, medical expert witnesses, life care planners and California QMEs. Those passes added 36 vendors that name those buyers on their own commercial pages.
  3. We coded a fixed rubric against every page we hold. A field is marked yes only when the vendor's own copy says it, and each yes carries the page URL, the capture date and a verbatim excerpt of 15 words or fewer.
  4. We pulled each vendor's sitemap, llms.txt and robots.txt on 2026-09-06 and 2026-09-07 to measure how often the site changes and whether it invites or blocks AI crawlers.
  5. We pulled Wayback Machine snapshots near 1 September of 2024, 2025 and 2026 and counted 7 marketing terms in each, to show how the category's language moved.
  6. We read 174 third-party reviews and 30 Reddit threads and coded them into themes. Only hand-verified quotes are published.
  7. We scored each vendor for each audience on 6 weighted components and published the component scores next to the total, so a reader can disagree with a weight and re-rank.

How a claim is scored

Each rubric field is scored from the vendor's own pages, never from a press release or a third-party listing. Strength records where the claim appears, because a claim on a pricing page is worth more than a claim in a blog post.

StrengthWhat it means
StrongStated at least twice on a key page, or at least 4 times across the site. Key pages are the homepage, product, pricing, security, solutions, platform, features, integrations, trust, compliance and about pages.
MediumStated once on a key page, or at least twice elsewhere.
Weak1 passing mention anywhere on the site.

Capture dates

WhatWhen
Competitor site scrape2026-08-13
Content hub profiles2026-09-01
Reviews and Reddit2026-08-13
Discovery passes2026-09-06
Sitemap, llms.txt and robots.txt pull2026-09-06 to 2026-09-07
Wayback targets2024-09-01, 2025-09-01, 2026-09-01
Rankings computed2026-09-07

Limitations

  • This measures what vendors publish, not what their software does. A vendor that cites to the source page but never says so scores low here. The study is about the public record, and a buyer reading a website sees the same thing.
  • Coverage is uneven by design. 55 vendors have a deep page-level scrape. 35 more were found by targeted discovery and scraped shallowly, so they carry evidence only from the pages actually fetched. The rest appear in the pool for completeness and are never ranked.
  • Update velocity can only be measured where a sitemap publishes lastmod dates. 60 vendors do. For the others the field is recorded as not measured, never as zero.
  • Wayback coverage is thin. The Internet Archive holds snapshots near all 3 target dates for 35 of the 55 deep-corpus vendors, so term trends from that subset are directional. Archive queries also rate-limited under load: the first pass lost 28 vendors, and a slower retry recovered most of them.
  • Review counts favor vendors that sell to law firms, because those vendors have public review profiles. A physician-facing product with no G2 listing is unlisted, which says nothing about its quality.
  • Prices are list prices published on a pricing page. Negotiated and enterprise pricing is invisible to this method, and most enterprise vendors publish no price at all.
  • Every count is a count over this vendor set on these dates. It is not a market share estimate and it is not a projection.

What we did not measure

  • Organic traffic and keyword rankings. No such figure appears anywhere in this study.
  • Regulatory text. Statutory and regulatory citations in the source checklist were not checked against current text, and none is used as a number.
  • Spreadsheet formulas. The source checklist is a workbook, read as stored and never recalculated, so no figure comes from a workbook formula.
  • Reddit directly. The 30 threads were captured through a third-party API on 2026-08-13 and are quoted only where hand-verified.

5 vendors in the pool block AI crawlers in robots.txt: mosmedicalrecordreview.com, ecsper.com, provalens.ai, doqtor.io and smartmd.com.

Composites and quotes

Where a report describes a buyer situation rather than a vendor claim, it is a composite drawn from published sources, not a survey. Composites are labeled where they appear, with the number of sources behind them. No customer, prospect or call participant is identified.

Review quotes are 1 excerpt per review, under 15 words, in straight quotes, linked to the review. Everything else is paraphrased and aggregated into coded themes.

Every table and chart in this series links to the page it came from. Where a page has changed since capture, the capture date printed next to the figure is the date that matters.

Court decisions cited in the reports

CaseCourtDateWhat happened
Kohls v. Ellison, No. 24-cv-3754, 2025 WL 66514D. Minn.2025-01-10Expert declaration excluded in full over fabricated AI citations. Court said counsel must ask experts about AI use.
Concord Music Grp. v. Anthropic PBC, No. 24-cv-03811-EKL, 2025 WL 1482734N.D. Cal.2025-05-23Paragraph of an expert declaration stricken. Credibility of the whole declaration undermined.
Matter of Weber (Michael S. Weber Trust), 85 Misc. 3d 727N.Y. Surrogate's Ct.2024-10Copilot-assisted damages opinion rejected as unreliable. Court held counsel has an affirmative duty to disclose AI use and that AI evidence needs a Frye hearing.
LeDouxx v. Outliers, Inc., No. 3:24-cv-05808, 2026 WL 2408808W.D. Wash.2026-08-18Expert report excluded under Rule 702 for hallucinated citations, then summary judgment entered against the plaintiff. Counsel sanctioned a month earlier at 2026 WL 2137370.
Unnamed medical expert opinionRegional Labor Court of Nazareth, Israel2026-02-03Medical expert report drafted with AI rejected. The expert could not explain reliance on AI conclusions that ignored newer studies.
Ferlito v. Harbor Freight Tools USA, No. 20-cv-5615, 2025 WL 1181699E.D.N.Y.2025-04-23Court refused to exclude an expert who used ChatGPT only to confirm findings he had already written from experience. The counter-example.

Common questions

Is this a survey?

No. Nobody was interviewed and nobody filled in a form. Every number is a count over a named set of vendors, taken from what those vendors publish on their own sites, with a source link and a capture date next to it.

What does it mean when a vendor is not counted for a capability?

It means the claim does not appear on any page we captured. It does not mean the software cannot do it. This study measures the public record, which is also what a buyer reading a website sees.

Can I check your work?

Yes, and that is the point. Every table links to the page it came from and prints the date we read it. Where a figure comes from an archived snapshot, the snapshot link is in the sources section.

Does Medrecords AI appear in the ranking?

No. We publish this study, so ranking ourselves against our own rubric would not be a ranking. The rubric and every input are public, so anyone can score us on the same sheet.

Shared sources

Each report lists its own vendor and pricing pages and links here for the groups below. External links are marked nofollow and open in a new tab. Earnings call transcripts sit in our own corpus and carry no public link, so they are listed by company and quarter.

Funding, acquisition and product announcements (5)

Earnings call transcripts in the owned corpus (8)

  • ExlService Holdings (EXLS), Q4 2025 earnings call · 2026-02-25
  • Verisk Analytics (VRSK), Q1 2026 earnings call · 2026-04-29
  • CCC Intelligent Solutions (CCC), Q1 2026 earnings call · 2026-04-30
  • Guidewire Software (GWRE), Q3 FY2026 earnings call · 2026-06-04
  • Marsh & McLennan (MMC), Q2 2026 earnings call · 2026-07-21
  • ExlService Holdings (EXLS), Q2 2026 earnings call · 2026-07-29
  • Verisk Analytics (VRSK), Q2 2026 earnings call · 2026-07-29
  • CCC Intelligent Solutions (CCC), Q2 2026 earnings call · 2026-07-30

Court decisions (5)

Internet Archive snapshots (33)

Reviews and threads quoted (4)

See it on a real file before you believe any of this.

Medrecords AI reads the file, cites every line back to its source page, and bills per deduplicated page. After the demo, your first case is free on us.