NewMissing Records Detection: flags every visit, provider, and date missing from the file. See how →
  1. Solutions
  2. Independent Review Organizations (IROs)

Case file review for IROs handling external review

The denial, the criteria it cites and 12 months of treating records in 1 dated file, each line tied to its page.

Case file review for IRO external review. Medrecords AI puts the case file in order: the adverse benefit determination, the criteria it cites, the treating provider's notes and every prior treatment tried, each line cited to its page. Your clinical reviewer starts reading on day 1 of a tight deadline. You review the record, and the reviewer decides.

Updated 21 Nov 2026

At a glance
Built forIndependent review organizations and the clinical reviewers who decide external reviews
What it readsDenial letters, internal appeal files, plan criteria, treating notes, imaging, procedure and therapy records
The denialThe stated reason, the criteria cited and each fact the denial relies on, with pages
Prior treatmentMedications, therapy, injections and other care tried, with dates and response
Treating providerThe requesting provider's notes and letters in date order
ConflictsPlaces where the denial and the records say different things, both pages side by side
File gapsRecords the notes mention that the case file lacks
SpeedAbout 1 hour per case
PriceFrom 10 cents per deduplicated page, as low as 5 cents with volume
SecuritySOC 2 and HIPAA, BAA at signup
TrialFirst case is free on us
What it does not doIt does not judge medical necessity, apply criteria, or uphold or overturn a denial

In a sample 342-page, 2-packet production, Medrecords AI found 11 duplicate pages. You pay for unique pages only.

  • HIPAA, under a BAA
  • SOC 2
  • About 1 hour per case
  • First case is free on us
1 member, 1 fusion request, 2 denials, 1 external reviewtap a point
Treating records
Denial and appeals
3 Feb 2025Denial letterDenial and appeals

Not medically necessary. Plan criteria require 6 months of conservative care including physical therapy. States no physical therapy is documented.

p. 5conflicts with p. 44
Illustrative case. The member, plan, denial and pages are fictional.
45days

For the IRO's final external review decision after it receives the request.

45 CFR 147.136
72hours

The outer limit for an expedited external review decision.

45 CFR 147.136
5business days

For the plan to send the IRO the documents it considered.

45 CFR 147.136
1 hourper case, on average

How long a typical case takes after upload.

Medrecords AI

Who should use case file review for IRO external review?

Case coordinators at independent review organizations who receive a plan's file and must route it, and the physician and nurse clinical reviewers who read it against a 45-day or 72-hour clock. If your reviewers spend the first hours of a case finding the denial letter and lining up the treating notes, it is built for you. If your files are short, you need it less.

Does Medrecords AI decide whether the denial should stand?

No. It sorts the case file and cites every line: the denial, the criteria named in it, the treating notes and the prior treatment, with the places where the denial and the records disagree. Whether care was medically necessary, and whether to uphold or overturn, is your clinical reviewer's decision.

What does an independent review organization's clinical reviewer need from the medical record?

An external review file is the plan's file plus whatever the claimant sent, sometimes in no order and with the same letter more than once. The clock started when the request arrived. These are the 6 things Medrecords AI pulls out for the reviewer, each with its page.

Denial

The reason and the criteria cited

The adverse benefit determination and the final internal denial, with the stated reason and each criterion named, so the reviewer knows the question first.

denial
Request

What the treating provider asked for

The requested service, the diagnosis, and the treating provider's own words on why, from the notes and appeal letters.

request
Prior care

Prior treatment tried and how it went

Medications, physical therapy, injections and other care with dates, visit counts and the response noted, since step criteria turn on these.

prior treatment
Findings

Exam, imaging and test results

Exam findings, imaging, labs and function scores by date, so the clinical picture reads in order.

findings
Conflicts

Where the denial and the records disagree

A denial that says no therapy is documented, next to the 12 therapy notes in the file, both pages shown.

conflict
File

What the file is missing

Missing Records Detection lists records the notes mention that are not in the case file, so the reviewer can ask early.

missing records

How does the denial compare with the treating provider's records?

The same fictional case, sorted 2 ways. The first tab follows the treating record. The second follows the denial and both internal appeals.

DateSourceFindingPageFlag
4 Mar 2024Primary care noteBack and left leg pain. Naproxen started.p. 31prior treatment
2 Apr 2024PT intake12 PT visits through 26 Jun 2024.p. 44prior treatment
26 Jun 2024No PT discharge summaryPromised in last PT note, not in file.nonemissing record
19 Jul 2024MRI reportL4-L5 spondylolisthesis, moderate stenosis.p. 73imaging
12 Sep and 6 Nov 2024Procedure notes2 epidural steroid injections, 2 to 3 weeks of relief.p. 80prior treatment
15 Jan 2025Spine surgeon noteRequests L4-L5 decompression and fusion.p. 91request
Fictional case built for this page. Real output has the same columns, and every page links to the source PDF.

What goes into the review, and what comes back?

What you send

  • The file the plan sent after assignment
  • Denial letters and internal appeal decisions
  • The plan's criteria or policy excerpts
  • Treating notes, imaging, procedure and therapy records
  • What the claimant or provider submitted
  • Any format: PDFs, scans, faxes, handwriting

What you get

  • The denial reason and criteria cited, with pages
  • The request in the treating provider's words
  • Prior treatment with dates, counts and response
  • Findings by date in 1 timeline
  • Conflicts between denial and record, side by side
  • A list of records the file mentions but lacks

We order the case file. Your clinical reviewer decides.

Medrecords AI does not judge medical necessity, apply plan criteria or evidence-based standards, write the decision, or uphold or overturn a denial. It puts what the file says in order, with pages. You review the record, check any line against its page, and your reviewer decides the case.

HIPAA, BAA at signupEvery external review file is handled under our Business Associate Agreement.
SOC 2Encrypted in transit and at rest, and access to PHI is logged.
No model trainingCase files never train any AI model, ours or anyone else's.
Deletion on requestYou set how long files stay, and they are deleted when you ask.

Which clinical review criteria did the denial cite, and what do the records show?

A medical necessity denial usually names its criterion: a number of weeks of conservative care, a failed medication, a finding on imaging. Medrecords AI lists each criterion the denial names next to the pages in the file that speak to it. Under 45 CFR 147.136 the IRO may consider the plan's clinical review criteria, practice guidelines and the treating provider's recommendation. How those weigh is your reviewer's call.

Criterion in the denialWhat the file showsPagesDatesFlag
6 months of conservative careNaproxen, PT, 2 injectionsp. 31, p. 44, p. 80, p. 83Mar to Nov 2024prior treatment
Physical therapy documented12 PT visits with notesp. 44 to p. 58Apr to Jun 2024conflicts with denial
Imaging confirms instability or stenosisMRI: grade 1 spondylolisthesis, moderate stenosisp. 7319 Jul 2024imaging
PT completion documentedNo PT discharge summarynoneJun 2024missing record

What prior treatment and conservative care does the file document?

Step criteria ask what was tried, for how long and how it went. The answer is spread across a primary care note, a therapy clinic and a pain clinic. Medrecords AI lines it up by date with visit counts and the response each note records. Whether it was enough is for your reviewer to decide.

DateTreatmentResponse notedPageFlag
4 Mar 2024Naproxen 500 mg twice dailyPartial relief at 4 weeksp. 31prior treatment
Apr to Jun 2024Physical therapy, 12 visitsLeg pain 7 of 10 to 5 of 10p. 44prior treatment
12 Sep 2024Epidural steroid injection, L4-L5Relief for about 3 weeksp. 80prior treatment
6 Nov 2024Epidural steroid injection, L4-L5Relief for 2 weeksp. 83prior treatment
15 Jan 2025Surgeon evaluationLeg pain 8 of 10, walks 1 blockp. 91request

What do federal rules say about the adverse benefit determination file?

Under 45 CFR 147.136, the plan must send the IRO the documents it considered within 5 business days of assignment, the claimant may send more within 10 business days, and the IRO decides within 45 days of the request, or 72 hours when expedited. CMS guidance says the review is de novo, not bound by the plan's internal decisions. The HHS-administered process covers denials based on medical necessity, level of care and experimental treatment.

Case file review for IRO external review: common questions

Does Medrecords AI decide whether the denial should stand?

No. It sorts the case file and cites every line: the denial, the criteria named in it, the treating notes and the prior treatment, with the places where the denial and the records disagree. Whether care was medically necessary, and whether to uphold or overturn, is your clinical reviewer's decision.

Does it apply the plan's criteria?

No. It lists each criterion the denial names next to the pages that speak to it. Applying the criteria, practice guidelines and plan terms is your reviewer's work.

Can it help on an expedited review?

Yes. A typical case comes back in about 1 hour, so the sorted file is ready early in a 72-hour window. The decision and its timing stay with you.

What if the claimant sends more records mid-review?

Upload them. The new pages join the same timeline by date, and exact duplicates of pages already in the file are set aside before billing.

Does it show where the denial and the records disagree?

Yes. When a denial says something is missing and the file has it, both pages sit side by side. What that means for the case is the reviewer's decision.

Does it request records from providers or the plan?

No. Medrecords AI does not retrieve records. You upload the file the plan and the claimant sent. Missing Records Detection lists what the notes mention but the file lacks.

Can the reviewer ask questions of the file?

Yes. Record Q&A answers questions like how many PT visits are documented, with each page cited.

Does it work for state external review and ERISA plans?

Yes. The case file sorts the same way whether the review runs under a state process, the federal process or an ERISA plan's procedure.

Is it HIPAA compliant?

Yes. Files are handled under a BAA signed at signup with SOC 2 controls. They never train an AI model, and they are deleted on request.

What does it cost?

From 10 cents per deduplicated page, as low as 5 cents with volume. Duplicate pages are free, and the first case is free on us.

Send 1 external review file. The first case is free on us.

Book a short demo. After it we open trial access on one of your own case files, the first case free on us, with the file back in order and page-cited.

Sources

Every rule, regulation, statute and published standard named on this page is linked below to the text the body that issues it puts out, read on the date shown. Where a standard is sold rather than published, the link goes to its publisher's page for it.