The definitions
The 3 are separated by intent and by who benefits, and a report that blurs them is easy to take apart. Malingering is a conclusion about motive, which is why it needs more than a single indicator.
- Malingering: intentional symptom production for external gain (Rogers' canon)
- Symptom validity tests (SVTs): evaluate whether reported symptoms are credible
- Performance validity tests (PVTs): evaluate whether test performance itself is genuine: e.g., forced-choice recognition below chance
- Not the same as: factitious disorder (internal gain) or genuine illness
The evidence base
A 2025 systematic review (PMC) estimates the prevalence of symptom exaggeration among North American IME examinees across observational studies. The forensic canon (Rogers, Larrabee, Boone) provides the test batteries and decision rules, including embedded vs standalone measures and base-rate awareness.
Common tests
Name the test, the score, the decision rule and the alternatives considered. Reported as evidence in a neutral clinical tone, a validity finding survives cross-examination; reported as an accusation, it does not.
Forced-choice PVTs (e.g., word-memory and recognition tests), embedded validity indices on standard batteries, and structured symptom interviews (e.g., SIRS-type instruments). Choice of tests follows the referral question and the assessed domain (cognitive, pain, psychiatric).
Defensible documentation
Report validity findings as evidence, not accusations: name the tests, the scores, the decision rule, and the alternative explanations considered. Flag effort or inconsistency in a neutral, clinical tone. Never base a diagnosis of malingering on a single indicator.
Why this matters for IME buyers
Validity challenges are the fastest way to destroy a report's credibility in cross-examination. Records completeness and cited evidence (Medrecords' core product) are the foundation: cherry-picked or missing records make any validity opinion attackable.