Free account 2:30Documents index and filters
Every document in the case in 1 list. Search, group and filter it, and open any record straight to its pages.
How to read WDL entries and blank flowsheet cells in a nursing negligence case
Under charting by exception, nurses chart only findings outside facility-defined normals. In court a WDL entry or blank cell can mean assessed and normal, or never assessed.
Nurses chart only findings outside a written normal; Medrecords AI cites them.
Charting by exception is a nursing documentation method in which nurses chart only findings that depart from written, facility-defined normal parameters, so a checkmark or WDL entry means the patient met that definition. In litigation a WDL or blank cell cuts both ways: it can mean assessed and normal under policy, or never assessed. The policy, the defined normals and the assessment frequency in effect that day decide which reading holds.
A nursing flowsheet is a grid of checkmarks, WDL entries and empty cells, and in a negligence case every empty cell turns into an argument. Under charting by exception the facility promised that silence means normal. The plaintiff says silence means nobody looked. The flowsheet alone settles nothing.
For plaintiff and defense med-mal attorneys, legal nurse consultants and nurse experts working a chart built on flowsheets. You walk away with the rules, the only well-known appellate case, a method for reading a blank cell, and 4 templates: a discovery request, 30(b)(6) topics, a gap log and a nurse deposition outline.
Charting by exception (CBE) is a bargain. The facility writes down in advance what "normal" means for each part of a nursing assessment: lungs, heart, neuro, skin, pain, sedation, the wound. If the patient meets that standard, the nurse marks the row with a checkmark or "WDL" and moves on. If not, the nurse charts the finding in detail. That entry is the exception, and it is the only narrative the system asks for.
An early description, "Charting by exception: meeting the challenge of cost containment" (Murphy, Beglinger and Johnson), ran in Nursing Management in 1988. Electronic flowsheets made the idea standard, and most inpatient nursing documentation you read in discovery is now a flowsheet grid, whatever the policy is called. So the useful question is rarely "did this hospital use CBE?" It is "what did each mark and each blank mean under the policy that governed this unit on this date?"
CBE is not permission to skip assessments. It covers documentation of normal findings only. The assessment still has to happen at the required frequency, and a changed condition still has to be charted and, where policy or the standard of care calls for it, reported to a provider.
No federal regulation permits or forbids charting by exception. Experts measure a CBE chart against general record and nursing rules, then the facility's own policy, then the standard of care.
"All patient medical record entries must be legible, complete, dated, timed, and authenticated in written or electronic form by the person responsible for providing or evaluating the service provided, consistent with hospital policies and procedures."
Plaintiffs quote "complete". Defendants quote "consistent with hospital policies and procedures". The regulation defers to the policy, which is why the policy is the case. The nursing Condition of Participation makes that policy binding on the nurses:
"All licensed nurses who provide services in the hospital must adhere to the policies and procedures of the hospital."
If the policy says sedation is reassessed every 2 hours on a patient-controlled analgesia pump, a 4-hour gap departs from a rule the hospital wrote for itself, before any expert speaks to the standard of care.
| Source | What it requires | How it is used in a CBE case |
|---|---|---|
| 42 CFR 482.24(c) | Entries legible, complete, dated, timed and authenticated; the record describes the patient's progress and response to medications and services | The baseline for any Medicare-participating hospital. "Progress" is hard to square with 12 hours of checkmarks before a crash |
| 42 CFR 482.23(b)(4) and (b)(6) | A current nursing care plan for each patient; nurses must follow hospital policies and procedures | Makes the policy's frequencies and definitions enforceable against the facility's own staff |
| 42 CFR 483.20 | Nursing homes: comprehensive assessment within 14 days of admission, quarterly review at least every 3 months, annual reassessment, 15 months kept in the active record; "The assessment must accurately reflect the resident's status." | Long-term care shift charting sits under these assessments. Willful false certification carries civil money penalties, capped per assessment at $1,000 and $5,000 before inflation adjustment |
| Facility documentation policy | The defined normals, the frequency of each assessment, what a blank means, how exceptions are charted and reported | The document the whole dispute is about. Request every version (chapter 9) |
| Physician orders and protocols | Frequencies for a specific patient, such as neuro checks every hour | An order can set a tighter frequency than the policy; the tighter one governs |
| State nurse practice act and board rules | Scope of practice, delegation, often a duty to document accurately | Varies by state. A nurse expert ties the chart to it |
Joint Commission standards and professional guidance also get cited, but their wording changes by edition, so get the version in effect from your expert. A nursing home chart also has a federal assessment calendar that a hospital chart lacks, which gives you fixed dates to check.
"Not documented, not done" is a teaching maxim, not a statute or rule of evidence. It captures a jury intuition: a careful professional would have written it down. CBE is built on the opposite premise. A nurse who found everything normal was told not to write it down.
Rule 803(6) admits regularly kept business records. Rule 803(7) lets a party use the absence of an entry as proof:
"Evidence that a matter is not included in a record described in paragraph (6) if: (A) the evidence is admitted to prove that the matter did not occur or exist; (B) a record was regularly kept for a matter of that kind; and (C) the opponent does not show that the possible source of the information or other circumstances indicate a lack of trustworthiness."
Condition (B) is where CBE changes the analysis. Under CBE, the regular record of a normal finding is the checkmark, and of an abnormal finding the exception note. That produces 2 arguments from the same rule:
Rule 406 then lets either side offer routine practice:
"Evidence of a person's habit or an organization's routine practice may be admitted to prove that on a particular occasion the person or organization acted in accordance with the habit or routine practice."
This is the defense's bridge across a blank cell: "I always assess every 2 hours on a PCA patient." Whether that is admissible habit is a fight for the evidence motions. Many states have their own versions of 406 and 803(7) with different wording.
| Entry on the page | Under narrative charting | Under charting by exception | What settles it |
|---|---|---|---|
| Blank cell at a time an assessment was due | Strong "not done" inference | Still a gap. CBE covers normal findings, not missed assessments | The policy's definition of a blank, the frequency rule, other time-stamped sources |
| Blank cell between required assessments | Nothing missing | Nothing missing | The frequency rule and any orders |
| WDL or checkmark | Rare; a sign of a hybrid form | Assessed and met the written definition | The definition in force that day, filed times, copy-forward settings |
| No narrative note for the shift | Suspicious | Normal if all rows were WDL; suspicious if any row was an exception | Any asterisk or comment with no linked note |
| Exception note with no provider notification | Weak note | Weak note, and may breach the policy's escalation rule | Notification criteria, paging and call logs |
| Identical values across many shifts | Copied text, easy to spot | Stable patient or copy forward; identical on paper | EHR metadata on how each value was entered |
Every article on CBE and the law cites Lama v. Borras, 16 F.3d 473 (1st Cir. 1994). A 1994 nursing-law newsletter ran it as "Court holds 'charting by exception' policy negligent," and that framing stuck. The opinion is narrower and more useful.
A neurosurgeon operates for a herniated disc and finds an extruded disc. The original symptoms return within days.
Part I, para 4No pre- or post-operative antibiotics ordered.
Part I, para 5A nurse's note records it. An expert testified this indicates possible infection.
Part I, para 5Another symptom consistent with infection.
Part I, para 5The last scattered entry before the crisis.
Part I, para 5No qualitative observations each shift under CBE. Temperature and vital signs were recorded; no fever appears before May 21.
Part I, para 5; footnote 3The patient spends the night in severe pain.
Part I, para 6Months of further hospitalization follow.
Part I, para 6The temperature and vital signs were there. The qualitative trend (the wound, the pain) was not, and the jury could find that gap delayed treatment.
The jury returned a $600,000 compensatory verdict against the surgeon and the hospital, and the First Circuit affirmed the denial of judgment as a matter of law. On the hospital, 4 points carry the holding:
"... the jury could have reasonably inferred that intermittent charting failed to provide the sort of continuous danger signals that would be the most likely spur to early intervention by a physician."
For plaintiffs, Lama is the cleanest statement of the CBE causation theory: charting only exceptions can hide a trend, and a hidden trend can delay the physician. It is also a model of proof: a regulation, a witness who described what the policy let nurses leave out, and a timeline that turned the gap into hours of delay.
For defendants, Lama is weak authority against CBE as such. It is 1 federal appellate case applying Puerto Rico law, on the deferential standard for overturning a verdict, and the breach rested on a regulation the hospital did not dispute. The court agreed with the trial judge that the case was "by no means the strongest proposition for medical malpractice against ... a hospital." A modern flowsheet with written definitions, frequent reassessment and escalation rules is a different system from the 1986 practice.
We did not find a later published appellate opinion on charting by exception that we could verify. If opposing counsel cites one, read the opinion, not the summary.
Printed flowsheets were designed for a screen, then flattened onto paper by a print routine nobody in the courtroom has seen. The mock page below shows the 7 things to check on every page before you draw an inference from a blank.
CBE grades each assessment on its own. A respiratory rate of 16, then 14, then 12 is WDL 3 times if the definition says 12 to 20. Oxygen saturation of 97%, 95%, 94%, 93% is WDL 4 times if the floor is 92%. No single cell triggers a note. The trend lives only in the numbers.
That is the Lama theory in a modern chart: the numbers are there, but nobody wrote down the direction. Plaintiffs should chart the trend themselves, cell by cell, with page cites. Defendants should be ready to explain what the policy told the nurse to do about direction as opposed to thresholds. Many policies say nothing.
Nurses change their behavior before they change their notes. A study at a large urban academic medical center tested that.
Collins and colleagues (American Journal of Critical Care, 2013) found that optional comments and vital signs beyond what was required were associated with death and cardiac arrest, reflecting nurse concern. Extra vital signs, all WDL, with no exception note, suggest someone was worried and did not write down why. Neither pattern proves the standard of care by itself.
The best-known measurement of copying comes from UCSF physician progress notes:
Less than a fifth of a typical note was typed fresh. The study covered physician and student notes, not nursing flowsheets, but on paper copied and fresh text look identical everywhere.
In a flowsheet the equivalent is the "previous value" function, and a WDL entry has no wording to compare. If the same 9 rows read WDL every 4 hours for 3 days, the print cannot tell you whether a nurse assessed 18 times or pressed a key 18 times. Many EHRs store how a value was entered. Ask for it by name (chapter 9).
The Braden scale for pressure injury risk has 6 subscales, with cumulative scores from 6 (highest risk) to 23 (lowest risk), per Alderden and colleagues (2017). A score drifting down 2 points a day may cross no threshold for days. The case often turns on the first date it crossed the facility's threshold, which the facility sets itself, and whether the ordered interventions followed.
| Time | Respiratory | RR | SpO2 | Sedation | Pain | Filed | By | Page |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 19:00 | WDL | 16 | 97% 2L | 1 | 6 | 19:04 | RN-A | 212 |
| 21:00 | WDL | 14 | 95% 2L | 2 | 4 | 21:02 | RN-A | 212 |
| 23:00 | WDL | 12 | 94% 2L | 2 | 3 | 23:15 | RN-A | 213 |
| 01:00 | WDL | 12 | 93% 2L | 2 | sleeping | 01:08 | RN-A | 213 |
| 03:00 | (blank) | (blank) | (blank) | (blank) | (blank) | none | none | 214 |
| 04:12 | (blank) | (blank) | 91% (V) | (blank) | (blank) | 04:12 | device | 214 |
| 05:00 | (blank) | (blank) | (blank) | (blank) | (blank) | none | none | 214 |
| 05:40 | * see note | 8 | 86% 2L | 4 | (blank) | 06:25 | RN-A | 215 |
4 WDL columns, 2 empty due times, 1 device number and 1 late exception. Every WDL on the page is defensible on its own. The page as a whole is not.
Page 219, a nursing note labeled "late entry", entered 06:25 for 05:40: "Pt difficult to arouse on rounds, RR 8, SpO2 86% on 2L NC. PCA paused, HOB raised, sternal rub, RRT called 05:44. Naloxone given per RRT 05:46. Pt restless and snoring since approx 03:30, repositioned x2."
The last sentence is the most important line in the chart for both sides. It puts the nurse at the bedside during the gap, and it records restlessness and snoring that a nurse expert may say called for a sedation assessment. None of it reached the flowsheet.
Order set repeats the policy frequency.
Orders p. 205RR falls 16 to 12; SpO2 97% to 93%; sedation 1 to 2. No cell crosses the defined limits.
Flowsheet pp. 212 to 213The last delivered dose is at 02:28.
PCA pump history p. 238No respiratory, SpO2 or sedation entry.
Flowsheet p. 214Known only from the 05:40 late entry. Repositioned.
Nursing note p. 219Validated as a device value. No assessment row filled.
Flowsheet p. 214Second missed due time.
Flowsheet p. 214PCA paused. Charted at 06:25 as a late entry.
Flowsheet p. 215; note p. 219Patient responds.
RRT record p. 241; MAR p. 230The flowsheet shows 2 blanks. The merged timeline shows a downward trend, the last opioid dose, a bedside visit during the gap and a monitor value below 92% with no assessment.
The gap is the case
The policy was followed where it counted
Both readings need what neither has yet: NUR-DOC-114 as of 11/14/2025, the sedation scale's action threshold, the monitor's alarm limits and history, how the 04:12 value was validated, and whether any 01:00 values were copied forward. Chapter 9 turns that list into a request.
Run every blank cell through the same questions in the same order, and log the answer. Each step can end the inquiry.
For the chapter 7 hypothetical, the sedation and respiratory log has 6 due times:
1 line per due time, not per blank, with a page cite in every line.
FLOWSHEET GAP LOG Matter: [CASE NAME] Patient: [INITIALS] Unit: [UNIT] Date range: [MM/DD/YYYY HH:MM] to [MM/DD/YYYY HH:MM] Reviewer: [NAME] Prepared: [DATE] ROW REVIEWED: [e.g. Sedation score] Frequency: [q2h] Source of frequency: [policy no./rev. date, protocol, or order + page] Defined normal for this row: [text, or "POLICY PENDING"] Policy meaning of a blank cell: [text, or "NOT STATED" / "PENDING"] Due time | Charted? | Filed time | Filed by | Value | Page | Other source in window (type, time, page) | Status [03:00] | [No] | [n/a] | [n/a] | [n/a] | [214]| [Note 05:40 describes 03:30 bedside, p. 219] | [Presence, no assessment] STATUS CODES Charted on time / Charted late (>[X] min) / Device value only / Gap, covered by other source / Presence, no assessment / Gap, unexplained / Not due / Off unit / Policy pending TRENDS INSIDE LIMITS (value, time, page for each point) [Row]: [16 @19:00 p.212] -> [14 @21:00 p.212] -> [12 @23:00 p.213] EXCEPTION NOTES Flag on flowsheet (time, page) | Linked note found? (page) | Note time vs filed time | Provider notified? (page) QUESTIONS FOR THE POLICY / METADATA / DEPOSITION 1. [e.g. How was the 04:12 SpO2 validated, and by whom?]
A HIPAA access request or a records subpoena gets you the chart, not the policy. The right of access in 45 CFR 164.524 reaches the patient's designated record set, and a nursing policy is not patient information. The policy, defined normals and flowsheet build come through party discovery, a subpoena, or a state pre-suit statute. Our guide on how to get medical records for a lawsuit covers the chart side.
Ask in the first request for production, not after the nurse's deposition. In federal court the other side has 30 days to respond under FRCP 34(b)(2)(A). A request for "all policies and procedures" produces the current binder, which may be years newer than the care. Name the date.
When a facility revises its defined normals, the same checkmark changes meaning. Here is a hypothetical revision of the chapter 7 respiratory row.
Under the 2021 text, the 04:12 saturation of 91% is an exception that called for a note, and with no 2-hour rule the 03:00 blank is not a gap. Under the 2024 text the 91% is WDL and the blank is a gap. Ask for every version from a year before the care to the present, with effective dates.
Adapt to your court's rules. Serve it with the first set.
DEFINITIONS "Date of Care" means [MM/DD/YYYY] through [MM/DD/YYYY]. "Unit" means [UNIT NAME / NUMBER] and any unit where [PATIENT] received care during the Date of Care. "Flowsheet" means any structured nursing documentation template, grid or row-based form, paper or electronic, used on the Unit. REQUEST NO. [__] Every version of each policy, procedure or protocol governing nursing documentation on the Unit in effect from [DATE 12 MONTHS BEFORE] to the present, including any policy on charting by exception, flowsheet documentation or "within defined limits" (WDL) charting, with effective, revision and retirement dates. REQUEST NO. [__] The written definitions of "within defined limits," "within normal limits" or any equivalent entry for each assessment row in [PATIENT]'s Flowsheets, as in effect during the Date of Care, including EHR help text, hover text or row descriptions. REQUEST NO. [__] Documents sufficient to show the build of each Flowsheet row in [PATIENT]'s record during the Date of Care: allowed values, embedded definitions, defaults, copy-forward settings and device-integration settings. REQUEST NO. [__] Every policy, protocol or standing order in effect during the Date of Care setting the frequency of assessment for: vital signs; pain; sedation during opioid therapy [or PCA]; neuro checks; skin; fall risk; [OTHER ROWS]. REQUEST NO. [__] Any policy in effect during the Date of Care on the meaning of a blank Flowsheet cell, and on late entries, addenda and corrections. REQUEST NO. [__] The legend for every symbol or marker on the printed Flowsheets produced. REQUEST NO. [__] Training and competency records for [NURSE NAMES / ROLES] on the policies above, dated within [24] months before the Date of Care. REQUEST NO. [__] Monitor data, alarm settings and alarm history, and infusion or PCA pump history for [PATIENT] during the Date of Care, in native or exported form. REQUEST NO. [__] For each Flowsheet value from [TIME] to [TIME] on [DATE], data sufficient to show when it was entered, by which user, and whether it was typed, selected, copied forward or accepted from a device.
The last request overlaps with EHR metadata discovery; see the EHR audit trail in medical malpractice guide, and altered medical records if an entry looks changed after the fact.
Only the organization can tell you what its policy meant. Under FRCP 30(b)(6) you "describe with reasonable particularity the matters for examination", and the designee must testify about information "known or reasonably available to the organization." Lock in definitions before the individual depositions.
Topic lists for an organizational deposition. State practice on corporate designee depositions varies.
MATTERS FOR EXAMINATION, [FACILITY NAME] 1. The nursing documentation policies for [UNIT] during [DATE OF CARE], their approval, effective dates and revisions from [DATE] to present. 2. The meaning under those policies of "WDL", a checkmark, "see note", a blank cell, and each symbol in the Flowsheet legend. 3. The written normal-finding definition for [LIST ROWS], and where nurses could see it (policy manual, EHR help text, other). 4. Required assessment frequencies for [LIST ROWS] for a patient in [PATIENT]'s condition, and the source of each. 5. How the Flowsheet system records when a value was entered, by whom, and whether it was typed, selected, copied forward or accepted from a device. 6. Criteria for charting an exception and notifying a provider. 7. Training and competency validation for nurses assigned to [UNIT]. 8. Audits of Flowsheet documentation on [UNIT] in the 12 months before [DATE OF CARE], to the extent not privileged under [STATE STATUTE]. 9. The search for and production of documents responsive to [REQUEST NOS.].
Download this guide as a worksheet (CSV), with Done and Notes columns.
0 of 10 checked
The defense usually runs 3 arguments together: each WDL is an affirmative record of a normal assessment under a written definition; the nurses followed a routine practice of assessing on schedule (Rule 406 or a state equivalent); and CBE is an accepted method. The paper behind the grid decides which of them holds.
Row-level definitions a nurse could apply. "Patient stable" undermines every mark on the grid.
Every required assessment charted at or near its due time. Most CBE defenses rise or fall here.
Each abnormal finding has a linked note and a documented provider notification where the policy required one.
Monitor data, alarm logs, pump history and MAR entries that fill a gap without relying on memory.
Proof the nurses were taught the definitions before the date of care.
Weakest alone. A nurse describing her habit invites the question of why the habit left no mark at 03:00.
This order is our view of how juries weigh the evidence, and it tracks Lama. Defense counsel should audit the chart against it before deciding whether to defend the documentation or concede it and fight causation.
For the bedside nurse, after you have the policy and the gap log. State rules on objections vary.
A. BACKGROUND AND TRAINING
1. When were you trained on [FACILITY]'s flowsheet documentation? By whom?
2. Were you shown the written definitions of WDL for each row? Where were
they kept? (policy manual, EHR help text, unit binder)
3. When did you last read them before [DATE OF CARE]?
B. THE DEFINITIONS (show Exhibit [__], policy rev. [DATE])
4. What did WDL mean for the [ROW] row on [DATE]? Read it into the record.
5. What does a blank cell mean under this policy?
6. What does [SYMBOL, e.g. (V)] mean on the printed flowsheet?
C. FREQUENCY
7. How often were you required to assess [ROW] for this patient? Source?
8. Show Exhibit [__] (gap log). At [03:00], what did you assess?
Where is it recorded?
9. Is there any record of an assessment at [03:00] other than your memory?
D. THE ENTRIES
10. For the [01:00] column: did you assess each row, or carry values forward?
11. How does the "previous value" function work on your unit?
12. The [04:12] SpO2 value: how was it validated? Did you see the patient?
13. When did you chart the [05:40] entry? Why was it a late entry?
E. THE NOTE (Exhibit [__], p. [219])
14. You wrote "restless and snoring since approx 03:30." What did you see?
15. Did you assess sedation or respirations at that time? Where is it?
16. Did you notify a provider before [05:40]? Where is that recorded?
F. MEMORY VS HABIT
17. Do you remember this patient, or are you describing your usual practice?
18. How many patients were you assigned that night? (staffing record)
A 5-day admission can produce hundreds of pages of grids, with the deciding facts scattered across them: a blank due time on page 214, the pump history on page 238, 1 sentence in a late entry on page 219. Legal AI tools are good at the finding half of that work. Do not trust them with the judging half.
In a charting-by-exception file, the question is always what the flowsheet shows on a given shift. Grounded, page-level citations send the nurse expert straight to that flowsheet, and a human-in-the-loop check of every row decides what the blank boxes mean. In Mata v. Avianca, Inc., 678 F. Supp. 3d 443 (S.D.N.Y. 2023), lawyers were sanctioned under Rule 11 for filing case citations a chatbot had invented. The same duty to verify applies to a chronology an expert relies on or a gap log attached to a motion.
Ambient AI scribes now draft some clinical notes from recorded conversation, and an accepted draft can read as complete while describing an assessment in general terms. Ask in discovery whether any AI drafting tool was used on the unit, and check a scribe-drafted note's times against the grid.
The market for AI document review, technology assisted review and agentic AI tools for lawyers is crowded. For CBE work, rank requirements in this order:
Every value, time and quote opens the source page. No citation, no use.
A business associate agreement before any record is uploaded. Consumer chatbots without one are out.
An independent security report and a written no-training commitment.
Grids, faxes and handwriting the OCR was unsure of, marked for a person, never silently guessed.
Stated time and filed time both preserved, never averaged or rounded into 1.
A log of who uploaded, viewed and edited what, for chain-of-custody questions about your work product.
See also is AI accurate enough for court, HIPAA-compliant AI medical record review and the AI-native legal nurse consultant manual.
Medrecords AI is medical record review software. You upload the records; it drafts a cited chronology, summaries and flags, every line linked to its source page. On a flowsheet chart:
Flags are signals, not verdicts. A time gap may be a missed assessment, a patient off the unit or a page missing from the production. A human decides which.
What it does not do: it does not know a unit's required assessment frequency or read the policy against the chart; the due-time skeleton is your step. It does not read EHR exports or entry-method metadata, so it cannot tell a copied WDL from a typed one. It does not decide breach, score case merit, give legal advice or retrieve records from providers. It works on the files you upload, under SOC 2 and HIPAA with a signed BAA (see security and HIPAA). Self-Service bills 10 cents a deduplicated page, down to 5 cents at volume, duplicates free; Enterprise On-Prem is an annual license.
See how this applies to hospital nursing negligence, nursing home neglect and legal nurse consultant work.
Book a demo on a nursing chart with gaps you need to explain, then run your first case free on us. Every line comes back cited to its source page. You review, you revise, you sign.
Scheduling only. No records move from a public page.
3 short guides from our help center, recorded on a demo case. They play inside the app: sign in or create a free account, and the video opens at the chapter you picked. First case is free on us.
Free account 2:30Every document in the case in 1 list. Search, group and filter it, and open any record straight to its pages.
Free account 2:35Every medical event on its date, in order, tied to the page it came from. Filter it, search it and export it as PDF or Word.
Free account 2:30Every record the case documents mention that the file does not contain, grouped by provider, with the page that mentions it.
Rules, regulations and the Lama opinion were read in full text from primary sources in September 2026; quoted text is verbatim. Study figures come from the published papers. The flowsheet, policy, patient, times and pages in chapters 5 and 7 to 10 are hypothetical. Product facts come from this site's product pages. Nothing here is legal or medical advice.
Related: legal nurse consultant reports and medical malpractice record review.