Free account 2:14Report studio
Draft a report from your notes, check every page cite against the records, edit it and sign it.
23 vendors say they serve California QMEs. We scored what each one publishes on citations, price and security, then wrote 5 tests you can run on a file whose report you already served.
Start with the tools that tie each line to a source page and tell you what the file lacks. Among the 23 vendors naming California QMEs, 9 claim source citations and 5 claim to flag missing records. Use the ranking to pick 3, then run them on a closed file. Every score here measures published statements, so none of them says a tool handles your file well.
| # | Vendor | Score 100 | Traceability 25 | Audience fit 20 | Transparency 20 | Review evidence 15 | Update velocity 10 | Openness 10 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3 | Doqtor | 56.2 | 16.2 | 20.0 | 10.0 | 0.0 | 10.0 | 0.0 |
| 8 | Docura | 36.2 | 16.2 | 20.0 | 0.0 | 0.0 | 0.0 | 0.0 |
| 9 | SecondLook Health | 36.2 | 16.2 | 20.0 | 0.0 | 0.0 | 0.0 | 0.0 |
| 10 | MRR Health Tech | 32.0 | 0.0 | 20.0 | 0.0 | 0.0 | 10.0 | 2.0 |
| 11 | Work Comp Medical Services | 30.2 | 0.0 | 20.0 | 10.0 | 0.0 | 0.2 | 0.0 |
| 12 | SMARTMD | 30.0 | 0.0 | 20.0 | 10.0 | 0.0 | 0.0 | 0.0 |
| 13 | Long Health (EvalPath) | 28.2 | 16.2 | 12.0 | 0.0 | 0.0 | 0.0 | 0.0 |
| 14 | United Medical Evaluators | 28.0 | 0.0 | 20.0 | 0.0 | 0.0 | 8.0 | 0.0 |
Each score is split into its parts, with the weight in each column header. Disagree with a weight and re-add the columns. The component scores are published so the ranking can be argued with.
We name 8 of the top 15 in this table. The rest appear by rank and score in the chart below, and the top 5 have their evidence linked.
Missing rank numbers belong to vendors this page does not name. Medrecords AI runs this study and leaves itself off the table, because a vendor grading itself on its own rubric tells you nothing. The inputs are public, so you can score us the same way.
All 8 named vendors score 0 on review evidence, so none of them can lean on third-party reviews. 4 of those 8 score 0 on traceability. 7 of the 8 take the full 20 on audience fit, which means naming QMEs barely separates them. Citations and written commitments do the separating: across all 23, only 4 reach 20 on traceability and 1 reaches 14 on transparency.
364 companies entered the pool. 90 had page-level evidence, and 23 of those name California QMEs on a commercial page. Showing up in a directory did not count.
top 15 of 23 eligible vendors, score out of 100
A vendor is ranked for an audience only when it names that audience on its own site and carries deep-corpus or discovery-pass evidence. Content-hub listing alone is not enough to be ranked.
The top score is 81, and the field falls to 26.6 by rank 15. Check the weakest line on each card below. 4 of the 5 sit at 0 on review evidence, so a high total here does not mean other buyers have vouched for the tool.
Strongest: traceability at 25.0 of 25. Weakest: openness at 2.0 of 10.
...of medical events in precise timelines with source citations. Date-indexed organization Physician notes extraction Treatment...
https://www.lezdotechmed.com · captured 2026-08-13
Strongest: traceability at 25.0 of 25. Weakest: review evidence at 0.0 of 15.
...using smart, categorized lists of key terms linked to source documents. Deduplication Remove duplicate records...
https://www.wisedocs.ai/blogs/hipaa-compliant-ai-for-medical-report-analysis · captured 2026-08-13
Strongest: update velocity at 10.0 of 10. Weakest: review evidence at 0.0 of 15.
...Every key finding links back to source pages so you can verify quickly...
https://doqtor.io/ · captured 2026-09-07
Strongest: audience fit at 20.0 of 20. Weakest: review evidence at 0.0 of 15.
...Page-level source citations Every finding in the summary links to the exact page in the...
https://www.superinsight.ai/ai-medical-records-summary.html · captured 2026-08-13
Strongest: traceability at 25.0 of 25. Weakest: review evidence at 0.0 of 15.
...The extracted data entries can be hyperlinked to the source medical record to facilitate cross...
https://www.mosmedicalrecordreview.com/process/ · captured 2026-08-13
We set the weights before scoring anyone. They are our editorial call and no market consensus stands behind them. If your worry is a party's attorney finding a prior injury you never saw, double traceability and drop update velocity. The component scores in the table let you redo the math.
| Component | Weight | What it measures |
|---|---|---|
| Traceability | 25 | Does the vendor say its output points back to the source page, and does it name contradictions, missing records, or duplicates? |
| Audience fit | 20 | Does the vendor name this audience on its own commercial pages, and has it built a real page for them rather than a menu item? |
| Transparency | 20 | Is there a published price, a named security posture, a business associate agreement, a no-training-on-your-data statement, and a stated retention period? |
| Review evidence | 15 | How many third-party reviews exist, and how do they split? |
| Update velocity | 10 | What share of dated sitemap URLs changed in the last 180 days? |
| Openness | 10 | Is there a public API, an MCP server, an llms.txt file? Blocking AI crawlers subtracts. |
Rankings built from scraped pages can reward whoever has the biggest website. The scatter tests for that on our own method. If the dots climbed a straight line, we would be charting our scraping and not the vendors.
23 eligible vendors, one dot each
If the dots climbed a straight line, this would be a chart of our own scraping rather than of the vendors. Read the outliers: a high score on few rows means the vendor states a lot in a small space, and a low score on many rows means we captured plenty and it still did not say much. Dots without a label are vendors we score but do not name here.
A panel assignment comes in, the exam date gets set, and records start arriving from the parties: treating notes, earlier claims, imaging, and often the same pages from both sides. After the exam the report is due on a statutory clock, with the record review inside it and a bill that depends on how pages were counted. Both parties read that report looking for what you missed, and the Medical Unit can read it too.
A miss comes back to you as a supplemental request, a deposition, or a question you cannot answer from the page in front of you. The case to plan for is an old injury to the same body part sitting in a duplicated stack that nobody sorted.
You still perform the exam, form the opinion and sign. The part software goes after is finding and sorting pages. The study's example is 6 hours spent finding the 40 pages that matter, cut to 1 hour confirming the tool caught them. That is an illustration, and nobody measured it. A plainer gain is the count: a tool that reports pages received and duplicates removed gives you a number to hold against your own record review and billing.
What you check first depends on your specialty. An orthopedic QME wants imaging, operative notes, hardware and earlier injuries to the body part in dispute. A psychiatric QME wants prior treatment and when each medication started, changed and stopped, spread across providers who never saw each other's notes.
For what the report itself has to contain, use our QME report requirements checklist and confirm it against the current rules with your own counsel. For the record side of an evaluator's file, see the medical evaluators page.
The study has 2 codings and they give 2 answers. The review-model field counts 10 of 23 vendors with a person reviewing output (nurse, physician or unspecified). The claims chart's capability line counts 4 of 23. This page will not pick a winner. Get it in writing from each vendor: who looks at the output, what that person checks, and whether a claimant's file reaches them. Take that answer with you when you ask your own counsel about disclosure rules.
The record below lists 17 dated events, 7 of them acquisitions. 1 vendor now owns ChartSwap and 2 other brands. HealthMark Group took in RRS Medical, MedRequest Solutions, Acton and Purview. Another vendor reported 8 acquisitions in 2020 alone, and 3 names a QME might shortlist already sit inside 2 holding companies. A claimant's history can pass to whoever buys the vendor next, so ask whether your agreement follows the data.
17 events, each with a source
Green is funding, orange is an acquisition, slate is a product event. Every row links to the announcement it came from in the sources section.
Entries marked Vendor are companies we no longer name on this site.
Your report gets read against the record, so a summary with no page numbers sends you back to the file and takes away most of the time you hoped to save. 9 of 23 vendors claim output that cites the source page, and all 9 say so on a product or pricing page. The other 14 do not make that claim on the pages we captured. Citations are the most common claim in this set, ahead of summaries at 7.
23 vendors, coded from their own pages
Denominator: 23 vendors that name California QMEs on their own site and carry page-level evidence. 16 state it on a product or pricing page. Captured 2026-08-13 and 2026-09-06. A bar counts vendors whose own copy states the claim. A missing bar means the claim appears nowhere on the pages we captured, which is not the same as the software lacking it.
The claims a contested QME file leans on are rarer: 5 flag missing records, 5 flag contradictions, 5 remove duplicates and 6 build a dated chronology. Handwriting sits at 4, which matters if your file holds handwritten treating notes. The 4 that review medical bills or charges are describing charges, and that wording does not promise help with your own med-legal bill, so ask directly. A short bar means the claim is absent from the pages we captured. The product may still do it, so make the vendor show you.
7 of 23 say they address causation or apportionment. In your report those are your opinions, so ask whether the tool pulls the records that bear on them or offers a conclusion. 1 vendor says it writes the report itself. Ask what it drafts from, and put the disclosure question to your own counsel before any such output gets near a signed report.
Wording matters as much as the count. In the table below, Docura promises links back to source documents, and SecondLook Health promises a specific chart entry and page number. Those are different promises, and only a click on your own file separates them.
8 of the 9 vendors that make the claim
| Vendor | What the page says | Captured |
|---|---|---|
| Docura | with links back to source documents for verification | 2026-09-07 |
| Doqtor | Every key finding links back to source pages so you can verify quickly | 2026-09-07 |
| Long Health (EvalPath) | source citations back to the original page | 2026-09-07 |
| SecondLook Health | Every finding traces to a specific chart entry and page number | 2026-09-07 |
One excerpt per vendor, taken from the page linked in the first column.
product or pricing page against everywhere else
A claim on a pricing page survives a procurement review. A claim in a blog post does not.
A QME file can hold a claimant's whole medical history. HIPAA is the most named security term here at 7 of 23, which is still under a third of the set. Naming a law costs nothing. The commitments a buyer's counsel can hold a vendor to appear less often: 4 rule out training on customer data, 3 offer a business associate agreement, 3 name a SOC 2 report and 1 states a retention period. Have the agreement and the retention date in hand before the first upload.
23 vendors, coded from trust, security and legal pages
HIPAA appears everywhere. The commitments a buyer can enforce appear far less often.
The count depends on the pass. The 13 Aug capture found a usable price at 8 of 23. The 6 Sep pricing pass found a number at 11 of 23, and the chart below carries that later figure. 7 route you to a demo form and 5 offer a trial or free tier in writing. Negotiated deals are invisible to this method.
| Vendor | What the page says | Captured |
|---|---|---|
| Doqtor | $0.10 per page processed, no monthly fee, no minimums, no contracts | 2026-09-07 |
| SMARTMD | 10.9 to 12.9 cents per line | 2026-09-07 |
| Work Comp Medical Services | 15 percent of total QME, plus a $100 virtual office fee | 2026-09-07 |
The table shows 3 of those prices, as captured, and they use 3 different units: per page, per line, and a percent of the total QME plus a $100 virtual office fee. You cannot rank those by eye. Run each against the page count, line count and fee on 1 of your own cases, then compare the dollars with the hours you would get back. Our cost study, which covers the wider market, counted 21 of 120 vendors publishing a price, per-page rates from 0.8 to 25 cents with a median of 10, and subscription as the most common unit at 8 of 21.
23 vendors that name this audience, coded from their own pages
Denominator: 23 vendors that name California QMEs on their own site and carry page-level evidence. 16 state it on a product or pricing page. Captured 2026-08-13 and 2026-09-06. A bar counts vendors whose own site states it. Negotiated pricing is invisible to this method.
The chart lists 12 claims, each with the number of vendors already saying it in public. A short bar means you are asking for something the category does not advertise, so expect to negotiate. Have each vendor show every claim on a file you supply. Then add the questions a QME practice needs answered:
23 vendors selling to California QMEs, counted from their own copy
Denominator: 23 vendors that name California QMEs on their own site and carry page-level evidence. 16 state it on a product or pricing page. Captured 2026-08-13 and 2026-09-06. A short bar means you are asking for something the category does not advertise yet, so expect to negotiate for it in writing.
Pick a real closed file of 200 to 500 pages and send the same one to each vendor, with the agreement signed first. A file whose report you served works best, because you already know the answer. Plant the defects from the 5 tests below and score every output on 1 sheet, including how long it took. The whole exercise costs less than a day and settles what a demo cannot.
This list draws on 50 published sources: vendor pages, public reviews, forum threads and court decisions. We ran no survey and spoke to no QME for it, and none of the 50 measures who belongs in a top tier. Treat it as a checklist and not a benchmark.
| # | Habit | Doing it | Sometimes | Not yet |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | They pick the file, not the tool | |||
| 2 | They check citations by clicking, not by trusting | |||
| 3 | They disclose AI use before anyone asks | |||
| 4 | They test for the missing record, not the wrong word | |||
| 5 | They price their own time before they price the tool | |||
| 6 | They keep the duplicate question in the contract | |||
| 7 | They keep the professional act unautomated |
Fill it in before your next panel exam. Anything under "Not yet" is a gap a party's attorney can find, and most of them close in an afternoon.
7 decisions sit in this chart, dated 2023 to 2026. 6 of them, those from 2024 onward, also appear in our study methodology, and 4 of those show what happens when the checking step is skipped. Kohls v. Ellison excluded a declaration in full over fabricated AI citations. Matter of Weber rejected a Copilot-assisted damages opinion as unreliable. A 2026 decision rejected a medical expert report drafted with AI. In Ferlito v. Harbor Freight, the expert wrote his findings first and used ChatGPT only to check them, and the court refused to exclude him.
In these summaries the objection falls on unverified or undisclosed output, and software alone did not sink anyone. We do not present any of them as a California workers' compensation ruling. This page summarizes reported decisions and gives no legal advice, so ask your own counsel how they bear on a QME report.
7 decisions on AI-assisted expert work, 2023 to 2026
Each one is a published decision, linked in full under sources. The pattern is that undisclosed and unverified AI use loses, and disclosed and verified AI use survives.
The study's headline count covers 74 public reviews of software and AI vendors: only 2 raise accuracy or error, 2 raise citations or source links, and 0 use the word hallucination. Support comes up in 33 and speed in 32. Buyers write about what they can see on day 1. A record missing from a 2,000-page file stays invisible until someone gets cross-examined about it. Take that as a warning about the reviews, and do not read it as a pass for the software.
The counts do not line up, and you should know that. The theme chart below, coded by regex sweep with every quoted row read by hand, shows 15 reviews calling the output accurate, 4 saying a record was missed and 4 saying a human check is still needed. We cannot reconcile 15 with 2 from the published study, so treat reviews as weak evidence on accuracy in either direction.
coded themes across 74 reviews of AI and software vendors
One review can carry more than one theme. Themes were coded by regex sweep, then every quoted row was read and verified by hand.
The harshest reviews target services. 62 of the 63 one-star reviews hit retrieval and examination firms. They complain about slow service, wrong records, follow-up contact nobody wanted and whether the examiner was impartial. An evaluator will recognize that last complaint. The 1 software one-star covers cost, support and the contract, and calls the AI feature barely usable. No one-star in this set says a summary was wrong. 16 reviews were read and verified by hand.
Forum talk runs differently. Across 30 Reddit threads, price appears in 22 and carries a coded complaint in 5. Slow turnaround shows up in 12 and privacy or data concerns in 9. Hallucination gets named in 2. The r/WorkersComp excerpt below is a claimant describing a human examiner, which tells you that parties already use this vocabulary about people in your seat.
coded themes across 30 Reddit threads
Price appears in 22 of 30 threads. Hallucination appears in 2.
| Source | Rating or date | Excerpt | What it shows |
|---|---|---|---|
| US Legal Support | 1 star | "we did not receive rough transcripts until AFTER out trial date" | A 1-star review of a service, and the complaint is timing. |
| r/legaltech | 2026-01-27 | "maintaining consistency, traceability, and contradiction detection across large multi-source records" | A practitioner naming where large multi-source records get hard. |
| r/WorkersComp | Undated | "the ime just made up non existing symptoms and evidence" | A claimant describing a human examiner, not an AI tool. The vocabulary of hallucination predates the software. |
Each takes under an hour and needs nothing from the vendor. Run them before the contract.
Every number here is a count over the 23 vendors that name QMEs (California) on their own commercial pages, each with a source URL and a capture date. This is secondary research, not a survey, so it shows what a buyer can read on a website, not what the software does.
Scoring rules, capture dates, limitations and what we could not measure are on the study methodology page.
179 sources. Every figure in this article traces to one of them. Vendor and pricing pages are listed here; external links are marked nofollow and open in a new tab. The groups below are shared across the series and listed on the methodology page.
3 short guides from our help center, recorded on a demo case. They play inside the app: sign in or create a free account, and the video opens at the chapter you picked. First case is free on us.
Free account 2:14Draft a report from your notes, check every page cite against the records, edit it and sign it.
Free account 2:31A cited first draft of the medical story, written from the records in date order, with a citation on every statement, for you to verify.
Free account 2:35Every medical event on its date, in order, tied to the page it came from. Filter it, search it and export it as PDF or Word.
Rank 1 scored 81 of 100, taking 25 of 25 on traceability and 2 of 10 on openness. This page does not name it. The highest named vendor is Doqtor at rank 3 with 56.2. The scores measure published statements, so use them to choose who to test.
23. A vendor counts only when it names California QMEs on a commercial page of its own and has page-level evidence in the study. The full pool is 364 companies, and 90 of them carry that evidence.
This study cannot settle that, and none of this is legal advice. It measures what vendors publish and does not address what the rules require of a QME. You still perform the exam, form the opinion and sign. Ask your own counsel what applies to you, including the disclosure rules, before you change how you review records.
11 of 23 vendors publish a number on the 6 Sep pricing pass, up from 8 at the 13 Aug capture, and 7 route you to a demo form. The captured prices use different units: per page, per line and a percent of the total QME. Work out each one on a real case before you compare them.
Buyers review what they can see, and turnaround shows at once. The headline count has 2 of 74 reviews mentioning accuracy or error, while the regex-coded theme chart has 15 calling the output accurate. We cannot reconcile those 2 counts, so test your own file for missed records.
We cannot tell you that. The chart lists 7 decisions from 2023 to 2026, and we do not present any of them as a California workers' compensation ruling. In Kohls v. Ellison a declaration was excluded in full over fabricated AI citations, and in Ferlito v. Harbor Freight the court refused to exclude an expert who had written his findings before checking them with ChatGPT. Ask your own counsel how they bear on your reports.
"Not only do you know how to write the computer program to do this (summarize medical records), but you also know a lot of the medical stuff that goes into it."
Yehonatan, psychiatrist (QME evaluations)
A dated, deduplicated timeline with a citation on every entry.
Question the whole record in plain English; every answer cited.
Every claim links to the source page it came from.
Rules, AMA Guides edition, and MMI standards by state.
Editorial reference on report writing, MMI, and validity testing.
Workers comp, claims, insurance and medical-legal conferences.
Rosters of examiners, LNCs, and expert witnesses by state.
All 10 verified state programs, side by side.