Free account 2:31Chronological narrative
A cited first draft of the medical story, written from the records in date order, with a citation on every statement, for you to verify.
Pre-existing conditions, and how prior records decide the case.
The eggshell plaintiff rule makes a defendant pay for the full harm the incident caused to a vulnerable person, but not for the pre-existing condition itself.
The eggshell rule covers extent; aggravation pays only for worsening, which Medrecords AI dates.
The eggshell plaintiff rule says a defendant takes the injured person as they find them: if a hidden weakness makes the harm worse than a healthy person would suffer, the defendant is liable for the full harm the incident caused. It does not make the defendant pay for the condition itself. Aggravation law limits damages to the worsening, and apportionment splits a single harm between causes when the records give a reasonable basis.
Almost every adult injury claimant arrives with a medical history: an old back strain, a knee that clicks, a neck MRI from 3 years ago, a chiropractor they saw for a season. The law on pre-existing conditions fits on a page. The fight is over the prior records, and whoever reads them first and most carefully usually frames the damages case.
For personal injury attorneys, paralegals, adjusters and IME physicians working a claim with a medical history behind it. You walk away with the 3 doctrines kept apart, the imaging studies that reframe degeneration, a worked timeline and 3 templates for a before/after record review.
Lawyers, adjusters and doctors use "eggshell plaintiff" loosely, as if it covered every claimant with a history. It does not. There are 3 separate ideas at work, and each 1 answers a different question.
The rule answers the question of extent: can a defendant argue that a normal, healthy person would have been hurt less? No. The Restatement (Second) of Torts puts it this way:
"The negligent actor is subject to liability for harm to another although a physical condition of the other which is neither known nor should be known to the actor makes the injury greater than that which the actor as a reasonable man should have foreseen as a probable result of his conduct."
The Restatement (Third) of Torts: Liability for Physical and Emotional Harm, section 31, carries the same rule forward and extends it to mental conditions and to harm of a different type as well as a greater amount.
Aggravation answers a different question: what exactly is the defendant paying for? The answer is the worsening, not the condition. A claimant with a lumbar disc that was already degenerated and already painful recovers for the added pain, added treatment and added limitation the incident caused. They do not recover for the back they already had. This is where the prior records carry the whole load, because "worse" only means something against a documented "before".
Apportionment answers the question of division: when 2 causes combine, can the harm be split? Section 433A of the Restatement (Second) says damages are apportioned among 2 or more causes when there are distinct harms, or when there is a "reasonable basis for determining the contribution of each cause to a single harm". A broken wrist in the crash and a separate knee problem from a later fall are distinct harms. A single disc that was degenerated and then herniated is a single harm, and it can be split only if the evidence gives a reasonable basis. When it cannot be split, many courts hold the defendant liable for the whole (chapter 2 covers who carries that burden).
| Question | Eggshell plaintiff rule | Aggravation | Apportionment |
|---|---|---|---|
| What it decides | Whether fragility reduces damages (it does not) | That damages run from the baseline, not from zero | Whether 1 harm can be divided between causes |
| Typical claimant | Hidden weakness, often no prior symptoms | Known condition, often with prior treatment | Prior condition plus the incident, or 2 incidents |
| Main authority | Restatement (Second) 461; Restatement (Third) 31; CACI 3928 | CACI 3927 and state equivalents | Restatement (Second) 433A; state case law |
| Who it helps | Mostly the plaintiff | Both: it caps damages and protects the added harm | Whoever has the better baseline evidence |
| Records that decide it | Post-incident treatment and the causation opinion | Prior records for the same body part, compared with post-incident records | Dated, quantified before and after measures: doses, visit counts, restrictions, imaging |
Download this guide as a worksheet (CSV), with Done and Notes columns.
Pattern jury instructions are the clearest statement of how a state applies these doctrines, because they are the words the jury actually hears. California splits the ideas into 2 instructions, and reading them side by side shows how the doctrines work together.
"[Name of plaintiff] is not entitled to damages for any physical or emotional condition that [he/she/nonbinary pronoun] had before [name of defendant]'s conduct occurred. However, if [name of plaintiff] had a physical or emotional condition that was made worse by [name of defendant]'s wrongful conduct, you must award damages that will reasonably and fairly compensate [him/her/nonbinary pronoun] for the effect on that condition."
"You must decide the full amount of money that will reasonably and fairly compensate [name of plaintiff] for all damages caused by the wrongful conduct of [name of defendant], even if [name of plaintiff] was more susceptible to injury than a normally healthy person would have been, and even if a normally healthy person would not have suffered similar injury."
Read 3927 as a fence and 3928 as a floor. The fence keeps the old condition out of the award. The floor stops the defense from arguing the claimant should have been sturdier. A jury that hears both is being asked to do 1 thing: measure the change. It can only do that if someone shows it a clear before and a clear after.
The defense has a counterweight to the eggshell rule. In Steinhauser v. Hertz Corp., 421 F.2d 1169 (2d Cir. 1970), a teenager with no physical injuries developed schizophrenia after a collision; the experts agreed she had a predisposition and that the accident precipitated the illness. The Second Circuit held the defendant liable, and said that if the defendant proves the pre-existing condition would have worsened anyway, the damages should be discounted for what would have happened without the accident. That is an evidence question. It turns on the trajectory in the prior records: stable, improving or progressing.
States differ here, and the difference changes how you build the review. Maine's highest court put the burden on the defendant in Lovely v. Allstate Insurance Co., 658 A.2d 1091 (Me. 1995), a case about an elbow injured in March 1985 and hurt again in an April 1985 car accident. As quoted by the federal court in Bouchard:
"single injury rule places any hardship resulting from the difficulty of apportionment on the proven wrongdoer and not on the innocent plaintiff."
The same opinion noted that even the cases placing the burden on the plaintiff to produce apportionment evidence accept that the defendant is liable for all of an indivisible injury. So the practical split is this: in some states, the plaintiff must bring evidence that lets the jury divide the harm, and in others the defendant must. Either way, the side without a documented baseline loses the argument by default.
Bouchard is worth reading in full for how a judge actually used records. The claimant had serious problems before a 2003 collision, including opioid dependence treated with methadone. The treating physician's records showed 10 milligrams 4 times a day just before the accident and a dose nearly 5 times that level afterward. The court treated that numeric change as the best evidence of the accident's effect, found the government had met its burden to separate out 1/5 of the post-accident methadone treatment as pre-existing, and found it had "largely failed" to apportion the rest of the claimant's combined injuries. The judgment was $1,100,000.
The lesson: apportionment is built on quantities from dated records (doses, visit counts, pain scores, restrictions). Adjectives like "chronic" do not split anything.
It helps to picture every body part in the claim as a stack of layers. Each layer has its own evidence, and each side is trying to move harm from 1 layer to another. The figure below is an illustration of a hypothetical lumbar claim, not data from any case.
The widths are invented for illustration. In a real file, each layer's size is argued from dated records and expert opinion.
A 2021 therapy discharge saying "goals met, pain 1/10, full duty" shrinks the baseline layer. A 2023 note saying "chronic low back pain" swells it. A 2025 fall down stairs creates a disputed layer on its own.
The most common defense exhibit in a spine or joint claim is a post-incident MRI that says "degenerative" and a prior study that says the same. The most useful response is the published prevalence of those same findings in people who have no symptoms at all.
The largest summary is a systematic review in the American Journal of Neuroradiology by Brinjikji and colleagues (2015). It pooled 33 studies covering 3,110 people without low back pain, almost all imaged with MRI, and modeled how often each lumbar finding appears at each age.
By 40, a majority of people with no back pain have disk degeneration on imaging. The finding alone cannot tell you whether someone hurt before.
The same table covers 7 more findings. Bulges climb with age like degeneration; protrusions barely move; facet degeneration and spondylolisthesis start rare and become common late in life.
| Lumbar finding (no back pain) | Age 20 | Age 40 | Age 60 | Age 80 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Disk degeneration | 37% | 68% | 88% | 96% |
| Disk signal loss | 17% | 54% | 86% | 97% |
| Disk height loss | 24% | 45% | 67% | 84% |
| Disk bulge | 30% | 50% | 69% | 84% |
| Disk protrusion | 29% | 33% | 38% | 43% |
| Annular fissure | 19% | 22% | 25% | 29% |
| Facet degeneration | 4% | 18% | 50% | 83% |
| Spondylolisthesis | 3% | 8% | 23% | 50% |
Other joints show the same pattern.
Of the people in the Framingham knee sample who had a meniscal tear on MRI, 61% reported no pain, aching or stiffness in that knee during the previous month. Englund et al., NEJM 2008, 991 subjects.
These studies cut both ways, and a careful reviewer uses them that way. Brinjikji's authors say their findings apply mainly to degenerative changes seen incidentally in people without back pain, and they do not claim degenerative findings are always harmless when they match the patient's symptoms and exam. So the numbers support a narrow point: a degenerative finding, standing alone, does not prove the claimant was symptomatic before. They do not prove the incident caused anything either.
What carries weight is change and correlation. A new extrusion at the level that matches new leg pain, in a dermatome no prior note mentions, is a different fact from a bulge that looks the same on both studies. That is why chapter 9 asks you to compare imaging by level, side and finding, and to get the images themselves along with the report.
A defense record review of a pre-existing condition claim follows a predictable order. Plaintiff teams should run it on their own client first. The ranking reflects how directly each item answers the aggravation question.
Primary care, urgent care and ED notes that mention neck, back or knee pain, even in passing during a visit for something else. The side, level and words matter: "low back pain radiating to left leg" in 2022 is a very different fact from "LBP" on a problem list.
X-rays, MRIs and CTs, with the impression and the date. The defense wants the same finding on both sides of the incident, and the phrase "unchanged from prior" in the post-incident report.
Visit counts, intake pain scores, functional goals and discharge status. A chiropractic intake questionnaire often holds the frankest history in the file.
Injections, opioid agreements, muscle relaxants and refill histories. A pharmacy printout can show ongoing symptoms that no visit note mentions.
A gap after the incident invites "the claimant got better, then something else happened". A short gap before the incident invites "the claimant was still treating".
Earlier accidents, workers' comp claims, disability applications, sports injuries and falls, before or after the incident. They show up in histories, in claims data and in intake forms.
Continuity: the same problem, before and after
Change: a new problem, or a clear step up
The history in a treating record is evidence. Federal Rule of Evidence 803(4) lets in, as a hearsay exception, a statement made for medical diagnosis or treatment that describes "medical history; past or present symptoms or sensations; their inception; or their general cause" (FRE 803(4)). Many states have a similar rule. A 2022 intake form where the claimant wrote "back pain on and off for 10 years" can come in against them. So can the post-incident ED note where they said "never had back problems before". Find both before the deposition.
Watch the copy-forward trap. A "history of low back pain" line repeated in every note for 6 years may trace back to 1 visit in 2018. Problem lists and past medical history sections get carried forward by EHR templates, and ambient AI scribes that draft notes from recorded conversation can now put an offhand remark into the history of present illness. Find the original entry and date it before you let anyone call the condition "chronic".
A baseline is not a feeling that the claimant "was fine before". It is a set of documented facts about symptoms, findings, treatment, work and activity during a defined period before the incident. The best baselines combine medical records with records that were never written for litigation.
| Evidence | What it proves | Where to find it | Weakness to expect |
|---|---|---|---|
| Quiet medical period | No complaints, visits or prescriptions for the region | Primary care notes, especially annual physicals with a normal musculoskeletal exam | Absence of complaint is not proof of absence of pain |
| Discharge notes | Prior treatment ended with goals met | PT and chiropractic discharge summaries | Many patients simply stop attending; no discharge note exists |
| Prior imaging comparison | Which findings are new at the matching level and side | The prior study's images and report, compared with the new study | Different machines, protocols and readers |
| Work history | Full duty, no restrictions, no missed time | Payroll, attendance records, job descriptions, employer testimony | Jobs change; the defense will look for light-duty periods |
| Activity | What the claimant did before: sports, gym, yard work, childcare | Gym check-ins, league rosters, photos, witness statements | Social media from the post-incident period can cut the other way |
| Pharmacy history | No refills for the region's medications | Pharmacy printouts, health plan claims | Cash purchases and samples leave no trail |
The strongest plaintiff baseline is a condition visible on imaging that caused nothing. It is also the easiest to lose: 1 overlooked urgent care note ends it. Prove it in 3 parts:
Prior treatment does not end a claim. It changes the job. Now the plaintiff must show a step change: new symptom types, a new level of treatment (from chiropractic to injections to a surgical referral), new restrictions, or a clear drop in function. The Bouchard dose comparison is the model. Pick the measures that were recorded before and after in the same units, and put them next to each other.
The file holds 1,140 pages from 9 providers. Page cites below use a provider prefix and page number. Each entry shows what the record says and how each side will use it.
Pain 6/10, no leg symptoms. 8 visits through August. Defense: prior treatment, same region. Plaintiff: axial pain only, no radicular symptoms.
CHIRO p. 1 to 22Mild L4-5 disc space narrowing. Defense: degeneration documented 5 years early. Plaintiff: common finding for age (chapter 4).
IMG p. 3Cyclobenzaprine 10 mg, 20 tablets. Defense: recurring episodes. Plaintiff: 1 visit in 16 months, resolved without follow-up.
PCP p. 31L4-5 desiccation, mild broad-based bulge, no stenosis, no nerve root contact. Defense: structural disease before the crash. Plaintiff: no nerve involvement at baseline.
IMG p. 7 to 86 visits. "Goals met, pain 1/10, returned to full duty." Plaintiff: the anchor of the baseline. Defense: pain was still present at discharge.
PT1 p. 185 primary care visits, including 2 annual physicals with a normal back exam. Last cyclobenzaprine fill March 2021. Plaintiff: a documented quiet period with medical contact. Defense: absence of complaint is not absence of pain.
PCP p. 40 to 66, RX p. 2Neck and low back pain, new left leg pain below the knee. ED history: "denies prior back problems." Defense: the denial contradicts 2019 to 2021 records. Plaintiff: new radicular pain no prior note mentions.
ED p. 2 to 9L4-5 left paracentral extrusion contacting the descending left L5 root. Desiccation "unchanged from 02/2021". Defense: "unchanged". Plaintiff: the extrusion and root contact are new, at the level and side of the new symptoms.
IMG p. 12 to 1318 PT visits; injections in August and October. Plaintiff: treatment level above anything before. Defense: conservative care similar in kind to 2019 to 2021.
PT2 p. 1 to 64, PM p. 5 to 19No visits; gabapentin refills continue monthly. Defense: improvement, or a new cause. Plaintiff: authorization delay, and the refills show symptoms continued.
RX p. 4, PM p. 20Restrictions: no lifting over 20 lb. Plaintiff: first-ever surgical recommendation and first restriction. Defense: surgery for a degenerative level.
ORTHO p. 44 to 47Both sides cite the same 11 entries. The case turns on 4 of them: the 2021 MRI, the 2021 discharge, the 37-month quiet period and the 2024 MRI.
For the plaintiff, this is an aggravation case with a strong baseline. An "asymptomatic before" theory would be false. The honest theory is better anyway: a treated, resolved lumbar strain with degeneration and no nerve involvement, followed by a 37-month documented quiet period, followed by a new extrusion with root contact and new radicular pain. Damages start from the 2021 discharge, which is a strong place to start.
For the defense, the ED denial is the most useful page in the file for credibility, and the 9-week gap is worth a question at deposition. But the imaging is the weak point for a pure "pre-existing" theory: the prior MRI says no nerve root contact, and the new one says contact at the matching level and side. An evaluation that ignores that comparison will be wrong.
For the IME physician, the report has to address each of the 4 anchor entries by page. An opinion that calls the extrusion "degenerative" without addressing the 2021 study's "no nerve root contact" invites the obvious cross-examination.
The moment a prior record surfaces is where most reviews go wrong, in both directions. Plaintiff teams panic and minimize it. Defense teams declare victory and stop reading. Run it through these questions instead.
The prior record changes the theory of the case. It rarely ends it.
A prior note is a map to other records. The referral in a 2020 primary care note points to an orthopedist. The "per outside MRI" line points to an imaging center. The pharmacy on the medication list points to a refill history. Request those before you rely on the baseline. Under HIPAA, a covered provider must act on a patient's own access request within 30 days, with 1 extension of up to 30 days, and may charge only a reasonable, cost-based fee (45 CFR 164.524). Requests by authorization or subpoena follow different rules; see how to get medical records for a lawsuit.
Use it at intake and again after the first production arrives. Fill in the brackets; strike lines that do not apply and say why.
PRIOR-RECORDS REQUEST CHECKLIST Matter: [CASE NAME] Claimant DOB: [DOB] Incident date: [DATE] Claimed body parts: [e.g. lumbar spine L4-5, left knee] Look-back window: [START DATE] to [INCIDENT DATE] Reason for window: [WHY] A. Providers the claimant named [ ] Primary care: [NAME] ............ requested [DATE] received [DATE] [ ] Urgent care / ED: [NAME] ........ requested [DATE] received [DATE] [ ] Chiropractic: [NAME] ............ requested [DATE] received [DATE] [ ] Physical therapy: [NAME] ........ requested [DATE] received [DATE] [ ] Orthopedics / spine: [NAME] ..... requested [DATE] received [DATE] [ ] Pain management: [NAME] ......... requested [DATE] received [DATE] B. Providers the records point to (fill in as you read) [ ] Referral in [PROVIDER] note of [DATE], p. [X]: [SPECIALIST] [ ] "Outside imaging" mentioned in [PROVIDER] note, p. [X]: [CENTER] [ ] Pharmacy on medication list, p. [X]: [PHARMACY] C. Records that are not visit notes [ ] Imaging: the images (DICOM) as well as the reports, for [STUDIES] [ ] Pharmacy refill history for [REGION] medications [ ] Health plan claims history for the window [ ] Intake questionnaires and pain diagrams (chiro, PT, pain mgmt) [ ] Prior workers' comp or disability claim files [ ] Employer attendance and duty-status records [ ] Prior accident claim files for [DATES] D. Close-out [ ] Every provider in A and B requested or ruled out, with reason [ ] "No records" certifications on file for providers with none [ ] Window and search method written into the review memo
The deliverable that decides these cases is a comparison, not a summary. A narrative of each visit in order is a medical chronology, and you need that first. The before/after review sits on top of it: the same measures, for the same body part, on both sides of the incident, each with a page cite.
1 table per body part. Paste into a spreadsheet or a word processor table. Every cell gets a page cite or "not recorded".
BASELINE VS POST-INJURY COMPARISON Body part: [REGION, LEVEL, SIDE] Incident: [DATE] Reviewer: [NAME] Look-back window: [START] to [INCIDENT DATE] Measure | Last pre-incident | First post-incident | Current | New? -------------------------|-----------------------|-----------------------|-----------------------|----- Pain score (0-10) | [X] ([SRC] p. [X]) | [X] ([SRC] p. [X]) | [X] ([SRC] p. [X]) | [Y/N] Symptom type | [axial / radicular] | [ ] | [ ] | [ ] Radiation / dermatome | [ ] | [ ] | [ ] | [ ] Neuro exam (SLR, reflex) | [ ] | [ ] | [ ] | [ ] Range of motion | [ ] | [ ] | [ ] | [ ] Imaging finding at level | [study, date, finding]| [ ] | [ ] | [ ] Medications and doses | [ ] | [ ] | [ ] | [ ] Visits per month | [ ] | [ ] | [ ] | [ ] Treatment level | [none/PT/chiro/inj] | [ ] | [ ] | [ ] Work status | [full / light / off] | [ ] | [ ] | [ ] Restrictions | [ ] | [ ] | [ ] | [ ] Activities stopped | [ ] | [ ] | [ ] | [ ] Gaps in care (dates, length, explanation in record with page): [ ] Other events before or after the incident (with page): [ ] Entries that hurt our position (with page): [ ]
| Measure | Last pre-incident | First post-incident | Current | New? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pain score | 1/10 (PT1 p. 18, 2021) | 8/10 (ED p. 4) | 6/10 (ORTHO p. 44) | Higher |
| Symptom type | Axial low back only (CHIRO p. 1) | Back plus left leg below knee (ED p. 3) | Same (ORTHO p. 44) | Yes |
| Imaging at L4-5 | Bulge, no root contact (IMG p. 7) | Extrusion contacting left L5 root (IMG p. 12) | Not re-imaged | Yes |
| Medications | None since March 2021 (RX p. 2) | Gabapentin monthly (RX p. 4) | Same | Yes |
| Treatment level | PT, discharged (PT1 p. 18) | PT plus 2 injections (PM p. 5) | Surgery recommended (ORTHO p. 46) | Yes |
| Work status | Full duty (PT1 p. 18; PCP p. 66) | Off work (ED p. 9) | 20 lb restriction (ORTHO p. 47) | Yes |
Hypothetical values from chapter 7. Notice what the table does not say: it does not say the crash caused the extrusion. It shows what changed, cited, and leaves causation to the physicians and the jury.
0 of 12 checked
The jury decides causation and damages, but it decides them on medical opinions, and those opinions are only as good as the records the physician saw. In federal court, a party's physical or mental condition can be examined when it is "in controversy", on motion for good cause (FRCP 35(a)); states have their own versions. For an overview of the exam itself, see what is an IME.
The IME failure that shows up most in cross-examination is asymmetry: quoting every prior complaint and skipping the discharge note. A report that addresses the strongest record for the other side survives deposition. For how evaluators get judged on their record work, see the IME physician field manual.
For a records-review letter, a treating physician conference or a deposition outline. Attach the comparison table from template 2 so the physician answers against cited pages.
AGGRAVATION QUESTIONS: [CLAIMANT], [BODY PART], incident [DATE]
Records provided: [PROVIDERS AND DATE RANGES]; comparison table attached.
Baseline
1. Before [DATE], what was the condition of [BODY PART]? Cite the records.
2. Was the condition symptomatic, treated or limiting work in the
[X] months before the incident? Cite the last pre-incident entry.
3. Were the prior imaging findings at [LEVEL] incidental, or did they
correlate with symptoms at the time? Basis?
Change
4. Which symptoms, findings or treatments after [DATE] had not appeared
before? Cite each.
5. Compare [PRIOR STUDY, DATE] with [NEW STUDY, DATE] at [LEVEL, SIDE].
Which findings are new, which unchanged? Did you review the images?
6. Is the mechanism of the incident consistent with the new findings?
Alternatives
7. Would the condition likely have progressed to its current state
without the incident? If so, when, and on what basis?
8. Do any events after [DATE] (gaps, falls, other injuries) explain
the current state better? Cite them.
Apportionment (only if your jurisdiction and the question call for it)
9. Can the current condition be divided between the pre-existing
condition and the incident on a reasonable basis? What measures
support the division?
10. To what degree of medical certainty or probability do you hold
each opinion above?
Pre-existing condition work is mostly finding and sorting: pulling every entry for 1 body part out of 1,000 to 5,000 pages from a dozen providers, putting them in date order and lining them up against the incident. That is the part of the job AI does well. Deciding what the entries mean for causation and damages is the part it should never be trusted with.
A baseline is only worth what its cites are worth. The defense will test every pre-injury line against the old chart, so each one needs grounded, page-level citations the adjuster can open. A human-in-the-loop review then decides which prior complaints were the same condition and which were not. Courts have made the stakes plain: in Mata v. Avianca, Inc. (S.D.N.Y. 2023), lawyers were sanctioned under Rule 11 for filing a brief with case citations a chatbot had fabricated. The same discipline applies to an AI demand letter or an IME report: open the page before the sentence goes out.
The market for AI document review, technology assisted review and agentic AI for law firms is crowded. For prior-history work, check these before any records leave your office:
| Requirement | Why it counts in pre-existing condition cases |
|---|---|
| A citation on every line | Every baseline entry must open to its source page, or it cannot go in a demand or an expert letter |
| HIPAA compliant AI with a signed BAA | Prior records are protected health information; no business associate agreement, no upload |
| SOC 2 | Independent evidence of security controls over years of a claimant's history |
| No training on your data | A claimant's prior records should not improve someone else's model |
| Handles scans, faxes and handwriting | The best baseline evidence is often the worst-quality paper |
| An audit trail of AI use | A record of who uploaded, viewed and edited the output, for defensibility |
| Leaves decisions to people | A tool that scores causation or apportionment is answering a question it cannot answer |
For more on the privacy side, see HIPAA compliant AI medical record review; for accuracy in litigation, see is AI accurate enough for court.
Medrecords AI is medical record review software. You upload the records you have; it drafts a cited chronology across every provider and date, so prior-care entries for the same body part land in order, each linked to its source page. It does not retrieve records, decide causation, apportion damages or score a case. Flags are signals for a person to check, not verdicts.
You review, you revise, you sign. The comparison table, the demand and the opinion are yours.
Book a demo on a claim with years of prior care, then run your first case free on us. Every line comes back cited to its source page. You review, you revise, you sign.
Scheduling only. No records move from a public page.
3 short guides from our help center, recorded on a demo case. They play inside the app: sign in or create a free account, and the video opens at the chapter you picked. First case is free on us.
Free account 2:31A cited first draft of the medical story, written from the records in date order, with a citation on every statement, for you to verify.
Free account 2:35Every medical event on its date, in order, tied to the page it came from. Filter it, search it and export it as PDF or Word.
Free account 2:30Every record the case documents mention that the file does not contain, grouped by provider, with the page that mentions it.
Rules, instructions, cases and study figures were checked against primary sources or published court opinions in September 2026. Quoted instruction text and the Restatement section 461 text are verbatim; the Lovely quotation is as quoted in the Bouchard opinion. Restatement sections 31 and 433A are paraphrased. Everything in chapters 3, 7 and 9 labeled hypothetical is invented for illustration. Product facts come from this site's product pages. Nothing here is legal or medical advice; rules vary by state.
Related guides: workers' comp apportionment and medical records, altered medical records, the AI-native personal injury law firm, personal injury plaintiff record review and personal injury defense record review.