Free account 2:30Documents index and filters
Every document in the case in 1 list. Search, group and filter it, and open any record straight to its pages.
How to review it in the medical record
The consent record shows a patient heard a procedure's risks, benefits and alternatives and agreed beforehand. A signed form is evidence of consent, not proof the conversation happened.
A claim a clinician failed to disclose a risk that caused harm; Medrecords AI cites consent.
Informed consent documentation is the record that a patient was told what a procedure is, its material risks, its benefits and the alternatives, including no treatment, and agreed before it began. In a hospital it pairs a signed form with the clinician's note of the discussion. A signed form is evidence of consent, not proof the conversation happened, and its time matters as much as its signature.
A lack of informed consent claim is a fight about a conversation nobody recorded word for word. The chart is the closest thing to a transcript, and most reviewers read only 1 page of it: the signed form. This guide reads the rest.
For attorneys, paralegals, legal nurse consultants and experts working a lack of informed consent claim. You leave with a form-reading method, a timing test, a worksheet and a deposition outline.
Informed consent has 2 legal roots, and the chart evidence you need depends on which one a claim grows from.
The first is bodily autonomy. In Schloendorff v. Society of New York Hospital (1914), Judge Cardozo wrote the sentence every consent opinion still quotes, and the D.C. Circuit repeated it 58 years later as "the root premise" of the doctrine:
"[E]very human being of adult years and sound mind has a right to determine what shall be done with his own body. . . ."
Cardozo called surgery without consent an assault. That framing survives for the cleanest cases: no consent at all, a different operation, or a different surgeon from the one the patient accepted. States classify those cases differently, and the label changes the proof. Texas makes negligence the only theory for a failure to disclose risks (Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code 74.101).
The second root is disclosure. The patient agreed to the operation that was done but was not told something they needed to decide. This is the modern lack of informed consent claim, a negligence claim almost everywhere.
Courts, CMS and the Joint Commission use different words for the same core list. The Joint Commission's 2026 standard is the most concrete (chapter 3 has the text). Reduced to what a reviewer checks:
Before 1972 most courts measured disclosure against medical custom: a doctor had to tell the patient what other doctors in the specialty would tell them. Canterbury v. Spence rejected that. The facts are worth knowing because they are a records case. A 19-year-old clerk-typist had a laminectomy on February 11, 1959. A day later he fell from his hospital bed while left unattended, and the lower half of his body became paralyzed. The surgeon testified that paralysis could be expected "somewhere in the nature of 1 percent" of laminectomies even without trauma, and that he did not think telling patients so was good practice.
One detail should interest any reviewer who reads consent timing for a living. The opinion records that the patient's mother traveled to Washington, arrived on the day of surgery after the operation was over, and signed a consent form at the hospital. A signature that postdates the surgery has come up before, in the case that built the doctrine.
"In our view, the patient's right of self-decision shapes the boundaries of the duty to reveal."
The court held that "the test for determining whether a particular peril must be divulged is its materiality to the patient's decision," and that the law, not medical custom, sets the standard. It also chose an objective causation test: what "a prudent person in the patient's position would have decided if suitably informed of all perils bearing significance."
Canterbury binds only the D.C. courts. States split: some adopted the patient-based test, some kept the physician-based test, some wrote their own into statute. We give no head count, because published counts disagree and states keep moving. Look up your jurisdiction's rule before you plan discovery.
| Question | Physician-based (professional) standard | Patient-based (reasonable patient) standard |
|---|---|---|
| What the jury asks | What would a reasonable physician in the same specialty have disclosed? | What would a reasonable patient in this position want to know to decide? |
| Leading authority | Pre-1972 custom-based cases; still the rule by case law or statute in some states | Canterbury v. Spence, 464 F.2d 772 (D.C. Cir. 1972) |
| Expert testimony needed on | What physicians customarily disclose for this procedure | The risk itself: its nature, likelihood and severity. Not always on what doctors customarily say |
| Records that help the plaintiff | Specialty society patient materials, the hospital's own procedure-specific forms, the defendant's past notes for similar patients where discoverable | Published complication rates, the patient's stated priorities (a job, a hobby, a fear) documented anywhere in the chart, portal questions the patient asked |
| Records that help the defense | A clinic note naming the risk; expert testimony that the risk is not customarily disclosed | A clinic note naming the specific risk that occurred; education handouts with the risk in them, signed or scanned in; a decision aid printout |
Ohio. Under R.C. 2317.54, a written consent that sets out in general terms the nature and purpose of the procedure, the reasonably known risks and (except in emergencies) the names of the physicians who will perform it, that acknowledges questions were answered, and that is signed by the patient or an authorized person, is "presumed to be valid and effective." The patient rebuts it only by proving bad faith, fraud, or that the signer could not communicate effectively in the language of the form. In Ohio the form is the case, and the language clause is where records work pays off.
Texas. Chapter 74 of the Civil Practice and Remedies Code uses a reasonable person test (74.101) and a state disclosure panel that lists procedures and the risks to disclose. Consent to a listed procedure is effective if it is in writing, signed by the patient or authorized person and a competent witness, and states the risks the panel requires (74.105). Disclosure made that way creates a rebuttable presumption of compliance; failure to disclose a required risk creates a rebuttable presumption of negligence (74.106). In Texas you pull the panel's list for the date of surgery and compare it to the form, line by line.
Steps 2 and 4 are the record questions. Step 2 is answered by reading every place disclosure could live (chapter 6). Step 4 is often answered by what the patient said and asked before surgery, which sits in portal messages and nursing notes more than on the form.
State tort law decides the claim. Federal rules decide what a Medicare hospital's chart should contain. 3 sections of the hospital Conditions of Participation cover consent.
Patient rights, 42 CFR 482.13(b)(2). The patient or representative "has the right to make informed decisions regarding his or her care." CMS's guidance adds that information should be "provided in a manner that the patient or the patient's representative can understand."
Medical records, 42 CFR 482.24(c)(4)(v). The record must contain "properly executed informed consent forms for procedures and treatments specified by the medical staff, or by Federal or State law if applicable, to require written patient consent." The medical staff decides which procedures need a written form. Ask for that list.
"A properly executed informed consent form for the operation must be in the patient's chart before surgery, except in emergencies."
The State Operations Manual is CMS's guidance to state surveyors. Tag A-0466 lists the minimum content of a properly executed form. It is guidance, not a statute, but it is the federal government's own description of a complete form.
CMS SOM Appendix A, A-0466
Same tag, "additional information"
The surgical tag, A-0955, was revised in April 2024 after CMS memo QSO-24-10-Hospitals. The memo responded to trainees performing breast, pelvic, prostate and rectal exams on anesthetized patients. The revised guidance says a well-designed process covers the surgery and anesthesia, material risks and benefits with their likelihood, alternatives, "the probable consequences of declining," who will operate, and whether residents, advanced practice providers or students will perform "important tasks," defined as "opening and closing, dissecting tissue, removing tissue, harvesting grafts, transplanting tissue, administering anesthesia, implanting devices, and placing invasive lines." It also tells surveyors to check that the forms "were executed prior to the surgery."
In a teaching hospital, a form silent on residents is worth a question, and the op note's list of who did what is the comparison.
From January 2026 the Joint Commission moved its consent requirement into National Performance Goal 7. NPG.07.02.01 says the hospital "honors the patient's right to give or withhold informed consent." EP 1 requires a written policy covering which care needs consent, exceptions, the process, which practitioners may hold the discussion, how consent is documented, and when a surrogate may consent. Its note matters for records work: "Documentation may be recorded in a form, in progress notes, or elsewhere in the record." EP 2 lists the discussion, including the likelihood of reaching the patient's goals, problems during recuperation, and the risks of no treatment. Older citations use RI.01.03.01.
Not following its own consent policy was the most common patient rights finding for accredited hospitals. Ask for the policy in force on the date of care, then hold the chart to it.
The eye slides over preprinted text and lands on the signature. Read the form the other way round: handwriting and blanks first, preprinted text last. The mock form below comes from the hypothetical file in chapter 8.
5 of 9 pins are problems with blanks, times or names, not with the preprinted text. That is where consent forms go wrong.
Researchers who read 540 procedure consent forms from 157 US hospitals found that 96% named the procedure, but only 26% included all 4 basic elements: nature, risks, benefits and alternatives. Forms from states whose statutes required all 4 were no more likely to include them. The forms read as built to authorize treatment and limit liability more than to inform.
A form that lacks risks or alternatives was the norm in that sample, so the disclosure evidence usually has to come from somewhere else in the chart.
The study is old, and forms have improved. The lesson holds: the form is a floor. A later interview study of 60 patients found that readers missed comprehension questions about consent forms and found them hard to read. If the defense's disclosure evidence is only the form, comprehension evidence (language, literacy, sedation, timing) carries more weight.
Put 4 times side by side for every procedure: when the discussion happened, when the form was signed, when the first sedating drug went in, and when the procedure started. Most consent problems show up as an order problem in those 4 numbers.
A consent signed after a sedative is the classic signal. Midazolam affects memory and judgment, so a signature minutes after a dose raises the question whether the patient could weigh anything. It is a signal, not a verdict. Dose, route, the last lucid nursing assessment and whether a real discussion happened days earlier in clinic all count. A pre-op signature confirming a detailed clinic discussion is a weaker issue than a form that is the only disclosure in the file.
The time on a consent can come from 3 places, and they do not mean the same thing.
| Source of the time | What it actually records | How to test it |
|---|---|---|
| Handwritten date and time next to the signature | What the writer put down. Could be the patient, the nurse or the resident, and could be written later | Compare handwriting and ink with the signature; ask the witness; compare with nursing and anesthesia times |
| Electronic signature pad or tablet timestamp | The system time the signature was captured, usually reliable to the minute | Request the native e-signature record and its metadata, not a printout |
| Scan or index date on a paper form | When health information staff scanned the page into the EHR. Says nothing about when the patient signed | Request the document history for the scanned image: scan time, user, index date, and any later re-index |
A paper form scanned 2 days after surgery can still have been on the paper chart before surgery. The pre-op checklist and nursing note are how you find out, because nurses usually record "consent on chart" before the patient leaves pre-op.
| Timestamp | User | Action | Object | Workstation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 03/27/25 06:58 | RN, pre-op | Note signed | Pre-op nursing note | PREOP-04 |
| 03/27/25 07:41 | CRNA | Medication given | Midazolam 2 mg IV | PREOP-02 |
| 03/27/25 08:12 | RN, circulating | Checklist item set | "Consent on chart: Yes" | OR-07 |
| 03/27/25 08:34 | RN, circulating | Event recorded | Incision | OR-07 |
| 03/29/25 14:06 | HIM scan clerk | Document scanned | Consent, surgical, 2 pp | HIM-SCAN-1 |
| 03/29/25 14:09 | HIM scan clerk | Document date entered | "03/27/25" typed by hand | HIM-SCAN-1 |
| 04/22/25 09:15 | Risk management | Document viewed | Consent, surgical | RM-01 |
| 04/22/25 09:18 | Risk management | Document printed | Consent, surgical | RM-01 |
A document history like this does not prove when the patient signed. It proves when the paper entered the system and who handled it afterwards. The EHR audit trail guide covers how to request and read these exports. If the form looks different across 2 productions (a time added, a line filled in), the altered records guide covers the next step.
The Joint Commission says consent documentation "may be recorded in a form, in progress notes, or elsewhere in the record." Defense counsel will search every one of those places. In most files the best disclosure evidence for either side is off the form.
Download this guide as a worksheet (CSV), with Done and Notes columns.
0 of 14 checked
The defense will say the real conversation happened in clinic, and that is where templated text hides best. "Risks, benefits and alternatives discussed" records that a discussion happened, not what it covered. Identical wording across months is copy-forward. If an ambient AI scribe drafted the note, ask whether the transcript was kept and whether the surgeon edited the draft. The charting by exception guide covers the same problem in nursing notes.
These are the cases where the right words went to the wrong person, in the wrong language, or at the wrong time.
Look at the hour before signing. Sedation, opioids, delirium, dementia and severe pain all show up in nursing assessments. Ohio's statute lets an authorized person consent where the patient is under the influence of alcohol, hallucinogens or drugs. If a representative signed, the chart should show why the patient could not.
CMS guidance (A-0131) lets a patient designate a representative, requires hospitals to go to an agent under an advance directive or medical power of attorney, and generally accepts a family member's claim to the role when an incapacitated patient named no one. State surrogate statutes set the priority order. In the chart, look for the representative's name, relationship, authority, and signature time.
The federal rule under Section 1557 of the Affordable Care Act, 45 CFR 92.201, requires covered entities to "offer a qualified interpreter" when interpretation is needed. It bars requiring patients to bring or pay for their own interpreter, bars relying on an accompanying adult except as a temporary measure in an emergency or at the patient's documented private request, and bars relying on a minor child except in an emergency. The Joint Commission covers interpreting under NPG.07.01.01.
In the chart: preferred language on the face sheet, the interpreter flag, the interpreter line on the consent, the interpreter ID in the nursing note, and the vendor call log. Ohio's rebuttal clause turns on whether the signer "was not able to communicate effectively" in the form's language. An English-only form signed by a patient whose face sheet says Spanish is the fact that clause was written for.
A parent or guardian usually consents for a minor. States carve out emancipated minors, services minors may consent to alone, and sometimes a mature minor doctrine. Check the rules in force on the date of care.
Canterbury recognized 2 exceptions to disclosure. The first applies "when the patient is unconscious or otherwise incapable of consenting, and harm from a failure to treat is imminent and outweighs any harm threatened by the proposed treatment." The second applies when disclosure itself poses such a threat to the patient that it is medically contraindicated. CMS expects hospital policy to define the emergency exception.
When an exception or a representative is used
Signals, not conclusions
R.M. is 58, a forklift operator with 14 months of right leg pain. The file runs 412 pages from 4 sources. After surgery on March 27, 2025, R.M. woke with a right foot drop that has not resolved. The claim: R.M. agreed to a decompression, received a fusion across 2 levels, and was never told about foot drop or the alternative of more physical therapy.
"Discussed options. Risks, benefits and alternatives discussed. Pt wishes to consider." No specific risks named.
Spine clinic note p. 104Same risks paragraph word for word as p. 104. Plan: "L4-5 decompression." Nothing on fusion, foot drop or continued therapy. Face sheet: preferred language Spanish, interpreter needed yes.
Clinic note p. 112; face sheet p. 3Daughter writes: "My father wants to know if he could need screws like his brother." Reply from a medical assistant: "Dr. will discuss on surgery day."
Portal messages p. 131"Surgical consent not on chart. Surgeon notified. Spanish interpreter requested."
Nursing note p. 214Midazolam 2 mg IV given in pre-op by the anesthesia team.
Anesthesia record p. 24111 minutes after midazolam. Procedure "L4-5 laminectomy and decompression." Alternatives blank. Interpreter line blank. Explained by a PGY-3 resident.
Consent form p. 219No call logged by the vendor for this patient on 03/27. The request at 06:58 has no follow-up entry anywhere.
Vendor log pp. 401 to 405"L4-5 decompression, bilateral" read and confirmed.
OR record p. 243Procedure start.
OR record p. 244"Instability noted at L5-S1. Decision made to proceed with L4-S1 posterior instrumented fusion." No note of any call to family during surgery.
Operative report p. 251The highlighted row is the signal: a consent signed 11 minutes after a sedative, with the interpreter request of 06:58 never closed. Neither fact decides the claim. Both need an explanation from someone who was there.
The second test compares what the form names with what the op note says was done.
How far an "additional procedures" clause stretches is a legal question that varies by state and facts. The records question is narrower: was fusion discussed anywhere before surgery? Here the only mention is the daughter's portal question, answered "Dr. will discuss on surgery day," and no later note records that discussion.
Each row still needs a person's judgment. The foot drop's cause is a separate question for an expert. Nerve injury is on the form, so the defense will argue foot drop was disclosed in substance; the plaintiff will answer that it was disclosed in Spanish to nobody. Neither side can make its argument without the page numbers.
1 surgery can produce 4 consents (surgical, anesthesia, blood, sedation), and a long admission dozens. Work from an index.
One copy per procedure. Fill it from the chart with a page cite for every answer. Leave a field blank rather than guess.
CONSENT REVIEW WORKSHEET Matter: [CASE NAME] Reviewer: [NAME] Date: [DATE] Jurisdiction: [STATE] Disclosure standard: [PHYSICIAN / PATIENT / STATUTORY] A. PROCEDURE 1. Procedure performed (op note title): [TEXT] p. [__] 2. Procedure named on consent: [TEXT] p. [__] 3. Level / side / site on consent: [TEXT or BLANK] p. [__] 4. Scope match? [YES / PARTIAL / NO] Added procedures: [LIST] 5. Surgeon named on consent vs operating surgeon: [NAME] / [NAME] 6. Residents, fellows, APPs, students doing important tasks (op note): [LIST] Disclosed on form? [YES / NO / FORM SILENT] B. DISCLOSURE CONTENT 7. Risks listed on form: [TEXT] p. [__] 8. Risk that occurred: [TEXT] Named on form? [Y/N] In clinic note? [Y/N] p. [__] Elsewhere? p. [__] 9. Benefits stated: [TEXT or BLANK] 10. Alternatives stated, incl. no treatment: [TEXT or BLANK] 11. Clinic note risk text copied forward? [Y/N] compare pp. [__] / [__] 12. Education materials or decision aid given: [TITLE, VERSION DATE] p. [__] 13. Patient questions in writing (portal, phone): p. [__] answered? [Y/N] C. WHO AND WHEN 14. Signer: [PATIENT / REPRESENTATIVE] Relationship and authority: [TEXT] 15. Signature date/time: [__/__/__ __:__] Clock: [HANDWRITTEN / E-SIGN / SCAN] 16. Witness name, date/time: [TEXT] 17. Explained by (name, role): [TEXT] 18. First sedating drug, dose, time: [DRUG, DOSE, __:__] p. [__] 19. Procedure start / incision time: [__:__] p. [__] 20. Order correct (discussion > signature > sedation > start)? [Y/N] 21. Last documented mental status before signing: [TEXT] p. [__] D. LANGUAGE AND CAPACITY 22. Preferred language (face sheet): [LANGUAGE] p. [__] 23. Interpreter on form / in notes / in vendor log: [Y/N] / [Y/N] / [Y/N] 24. Capacity concerns documented before signing: [TEXT] p. [__] 25. Emergency claimed? Basis documented: [TEXT] p. [__] E. FORM INTEGRITY 26. Form number and revision date: [TEXT] 27. Blank fields: [LIST] 28. Strike-throughs, other ink, added lines: [LIST] 29. Scan / index date: [DATE] 30. Same form in every production? [Y/N] differences: [LIST] F. OPEN ITEMS AND REQUESTS [LIST, each with the page that implies it exists]
A standard chart request misses much of the consent evidence. Policies, form revisions, e-signature metadata and interpreter logs often sit outside what a records department produces by default. The records request guide covers authorizations and subpoenas; patients requesting their own records are owed action within 30 days under 45 CFR 164.524.
Add these to the first request for a surgical admission: every consent form in native electronic form with signature pad metadata; the document history for any scanned form; the consent policy, the medical staff list of procedures needing written consent, and the blank form revision in force on the date of surgery; the pre-op checklist, anesthesia record and MAR; interpreter requests and vendor call logs; education materials with version dates; portal messages and phone encounters before surgery; the booking request; the time-out record; and the EHR audit trail for the consent and the pre-op and operative notes. If a clinic note was drafted by an ambient scribe, ask for the tool's retention policy and any retained transcript.
Most surgeons will not remember the conversation. Expect "my usual practice." Pin the habit to specifics first, then bring out the documents.
For the attending surgeon or the resident who signed "explained by." Reorder to your case. Every document reference should carry a page cite.
DEPOSITION OUTLINE: CONSENTING PHYSICIAN
Witness: [NAME, ROLE] Procedure: [PROCEDURE, DATE]
I. BACKGROUND
1. Training, years performing [PROCEDURE], annual volume.
2. Who in your practice obtains consent: you, residents, PAs, nurses?
3. Hospital policy on who may obtain consent. Have you read it?
II. USUAL PRACTICE (before showing any document)
4. Walk me through your usual consent discussion for [PROCEDURE].
5. Which risks do you always name? Which do you name only sometimes?
6. Do you give incidence figures? What figure do you use for [RISK]?
7. Which alternatives do you always describe, incl. nonoperative care?
8. Do you discuss what happens if you find something unexpected?
9. Do you use handouts, videos or decision aids? Which versions?
10. How do you handle patients with limited English proficiency?
III. THIS PATIENT: THE CLINIC DISCUSSION
11. [Show clinic note p. __] Who wrote this? Dictated, typed, template,
or drafted by an ambient scribe? When signed?
12. Compare with note p. __. Why is the risk paragraph identical?
13. Which risks did you name to this patient? Where is that written?
14. Was [RISK THAT OCCURRED] discussed? Where does the record show it?
15. Was an interpreter present? Name? Where is that documented?
IV. THE FORM
16. [Show consent p. __] Whose handwriting is on each line?
17. Who filled in the procedure line? When?
18. Why is the side / alternatives / blood line blank?
19. Who is "[NAME]" on "explained by"? Were you present?
20. The patient signed at [TIME]. Where were you at that time?
21. [Show anesthesia record p. __] Midazolam at [TIME]. Were you aware?
22. Is it your practice to have consent signed after sedation?
23. Hospital policy on consent after pre-medication?
V. SCOPE
24. [Show op note p. __] When did you first consider [ADDED PROCEDURE]?
25. Was it discussed before surgery? Where is that recorded?
26. [Show portal message p. __] Did anyone tell you about this question?
27. Did you or anyone contact family during surgery? Documented where?
28. Which parts did residents or others perform? Was the patient told?
VI. AFTERWARDS
29. When was the consent form scanned? Did you see it after surgery?
30. Any late entry, addendum or edit to your notes? When and why?
31. Any conversation with the patient about the complication? Documented?
For transcripts already taken, a deposition digest with page and line cites separates habit testimony from testimony about this patient. The clinical guidelines guide covers the standard of care claim that often travels with consent.
Consent review is a sequencing job over a large file, which AI medical record review handles well, and a judgment job about 1 or 2 pages, which it should not be trusted with. The workable setup is human-in-the-loop: the software orders and cites, a person reads and decides.
A large language model with clinical NLP can pull every dated event from a few thousand pages into order. That is the step that surfaced chapter 8's signal: a consent time on 1 page and a sedation time 22 pages later. An AI medical chronology with each line linked to its source page lets a person see the order and check it at the page.
It also speeds chapter 6's search work: "where is foot drop, nerve injury or peroneal mentioned before 03/27?" answered with page cites you can confirm.
Medrecords AI drafts a cited medical chronology from the files you upload, with a citation on every line to its source page. On a surgical file, that puts the dated entry for the consent form next to the pre-op nursing note, the first sedative and the incision time, so a person can see the sequence and open each page. OCR routes each page to the right engine for typed text, handwriting and tables and flags low-confidence pages, which is where handwritten consent times tend to land. Questions answered from the record and search across the file find risk language and interpreter mentions with citations.
It does not find, count or judge consent forms for you. It does not decide whether a signature came too late, whether a risk was material or whether a clause covered a procedure. It flags things for a person to look at, and a flag is a signal, not a verdict. It does not retrieve records from providers; you upload what you have. You review, you revise, you sign.
A page-level citation on every fact, opening the page it came from. If a line has no citation, you cannot use it and should not have to fix it.
A business associate agreement before any record is uploaded, plus SOC 2. Ask which subprocessors see the data.
In writing, in the contract. Client medical records should not improve someone else's model.
The tool should tell you which handwritten or faxed pages it could not read well, so you know where to look yourself.
Who uploaded what, when, and what the output was. If opposing counsel asks how a chronology was built, you want an answer on paper.
More on the court side in Is AI accurate enough for court?, and on privacy in the HIPAA compliant AI guide. For legal nurse consultants building this into a practice, see the AI-native legal nurse consultant manual.
Book a demo on a surgical file, then run your first case free on us. Every line comes back cited to its source page. You review, you revise, you sign.
Scheduling only. No records move from a public page.
Regulatory text was read from the current eCFR on the date of publication. CMS guidance was read from the State Operations Manual, Appendix A, and the April 2024 memo. Case facts and quotes come from the published opinion. Study figures come from the PubMed abstracts. The worked example, the mock form and the document history are hypothetical and labeled so. We removed any claim we could not tie to a primary source, including a count of states using each disclosure standard.
3 short guides from our help center, recorded on a demo case. They play inside the app: sign in or create a free account, and the video opens at the chapter you picked. First case is free on us.
Free account 2:30Every document in the case in 1 list. Search, group and filter it, and open any record straight to its pages.
Free account 2:35Every medical event on its date, in order, tied to the page it came from. Filter it, search it and export it as PDF or Word.
Free account 2:30Every record the case documents mention that the file does not contain, grouped by provider, with the page that mentions it.